I totally get what Otto is saying. I think it's like magic -- after awhile the tricks just wear thin.
It is harder and harder to be genuinely surprised by a movie. But still, every now and again, a surprise comes along. And it is just so welcome. That doesn't mean it has to be a "great" film by any stretch -- just that it touches you in the same way that films of the past may have done.
Most recently, from the big franchises, I got that sensation from "Rogue One" (not a brilliant movie but there's just something about it that harkens back for me) and I got that sensation from "Infinity War" (which I still enjoy rewatching). There's a few others -- The Winter Soldier, GOTG, The Martian, to name a few...