I liked the DCD stuff. I had all 4 of the originals and back in 2004 I thought they were superb. Yeah, I was bummed that Batman only looked good in ONE pose, but it was better than nothing, which is what I had for years! I also got the two-pack with Batman and Joker repaints and those were cool too.
Passed on the 4-pack cause none of them improved on the initial releases, and in my opinion, looked worse actually.
I will defend the DCD Batman....I think it's SOOO much better than the Mattel one. Look at the sculpting. Look at the lines and cracks in his face. The texture and wrinkles all over his costume. His belt! His musculature...like that of a once-powerful 55 year old man. Not a freaking He-Man body!! With soft mass-produced textures and a face that looks like he's squeezing one out. DCD managed to capture the grizzled look of the original artwork. I get it...the Mattel one was poseable and the DCD one wasn't. But that ONE point certainly doesn't make it a superior figure!
It's all moot anyway....soon Mezco is gonna retire all those old versions from my shelf!
Actually, you could say the Superman got better, the 4 pack Superman has a better face paint job than the original individual release, I had them both and liked them both but the 4 Pack Superman was just a tad better in the face.
Moving to the DCD Batman, yeah for the time it was great, and it does resemble the book, but more lines doesn't = a better sculpt, it is a good sculpt but I don't think they got the vibe of the art like the Mattel one did, it was a softer sculpt but the lines are in all the right places, you just get that Miller feel out of that sculpt, on the body, the only panel I see Batman all hunched down and looking like an actual old man, is when he's laying next to the Joker, the rest of the time he looks to be built like a tank, which is why I think the He-man body works so well, and of course the articulation is a huge plus.
Yeah the sculpt in the body is pretty good on the DCD but the He-man body works better for the figure, besides the mattel has a pretty cool pair of trunks, gloves and boots that are much better than the DCD and the cape on the mattel one is just great.
Oh and I forgot about the gorilla hands on the DCD
they're way out of proportion.
I actually thought about selling my Mattel TDKR Batmen when these Mezco ones were announced but they're too good and too much fun to play with.