Antman84
Super Freak
It does look fantastic next to the shield if only the official shield looked like that
Museum Replicas Thor Hammer
- Thread starter vader70450
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
I'm thinking about cancelling my order. Most everyone that's gotten theirs already, say it's crap. The handle is the major gripe, along with the lines in the head being very poorly cut. People that have both, say the Dr. Pepper hammer is much better for the price.
I hate it because I was really looking forward to having a well made, heavy Mjolnir with a metal head.
galmando
Super Freak
I know what you mean, as far as wanting a nice, heavy and weighty Mjolnir goes, then i'm happy, but the craftsmanship leaves a lot to be desired in some places
The actual hammer head on mine is okay, the lines don't seem to have been cut too far over and the symbols on the edges a clear, the only problem i had was the top circke piece with the runes inscribed on it, the top if the hammer isn't perfectly flat so the circle piece doesn't fit flush
It's the handle that could have been vastly improved, for one the colour is wrong, it's too dark, but the silver striping could have been applied with far more quality.
It's alao on the wrong way
the stitching should be facing the long side of the hammer head, not sure if I can fix this and dye the leatherShouldn't have to though. But despite this list, i do like it abd it'll go great with my collection when i get it all presented better
Antman84
Super Freak
I'm guessing the silver handle would be an easy fix
yeek
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2008
- Messages
- 1,019
- Reaction score
- 1
Personally, I love mine. I like the feel and solid hefty weight of the hammer. Once a day I'll pick it up and swing around just for kicks. But you all are right. In terms of accuracy and craftsmanship, it's severely lacking. For something that was so costly, it should have been flawless in every detail. I guess museum replicas has a reputation for just half hearted efforts.
No complaints whatsover?? The handles are flawless? Can you post some pics of yours?
Socko
Super Freak
Yes, it's very solid and nice 'n' weighty!
Looks great next to the Captain America Movie Shield!
Can't wait to get the loft straightened up so i can get a nice display unit for them
What a friggin' awesome picture!!! Thanks for sharing that!
The handles are not flawless, the silver paint on the handle is not as smooth and thick as I would like, but the overall display of the piece makes up for it. Just like any collectible, it can be nit picked to death. Every sideshow statue I own (many), I could go around the statue and pick it apart with flaws.
It is what it is, and still makes a great display. Everyone that comes in my office is loving it...and yes everyone has to grab it and swing it around.
No regrets on my purchase.
DFanatic
Super Freak
Guy, go with the eFx version. I saw this one in person and it looks tiny and sort of toyish. The eFx is the closest you'll get to a proper Thor hammer replica. Watch this video and see for yourself!
https://www.comicvine.com/wondercon-2012-efx-collectibles/112-1757/
DFanatic
Super Freak
No, but it's planned for Q1/Q2. You got to pre-order soon though. They are only making 1000 of those and they are no longer taking orders at their website. Big Bad Toy Store still has it for pre-order... that's where I'm getting mine from.
Hi Everyone,
I am obsessed with the Thor films and the concept of Thor's hammer..etc.
This is what I currently own and my critiques for each in case anyone wants a true comparison of the higher end 'licensed' models out there:
-Museum Replicas/Sideshow Thor Hammer from the first movie:
This one looks great from a distance and a nice piece to have in your living room. As long as nobody comes too close to it…which believe me is unavoidable... Now: up-close once you check the runes/finishing of the hammer head: the lousy work done on the details and poor craftsmanship is visible and a true shame. This hammer's movie design is significant cause it's the original we all saw in the first movie... from the ending of Iron Man 2 and the first THOR movie when people were trying to pull it off the ground... Epic... It's a damn shame that the Museum Replicas guys didn't put the right effort here... seriously poor and rushed overall job. But like I said: from a distance is looks good... up-close: tragically bad. Features: Real metal head, real leather handle and strap. But the metal used for the head is just overall bad... The lines are not straight, the details are blurry and messed up... Overall shame. But I repeat: from FAR it looks amazing especially the way it looks when placed in the original stand it comes with. The stand for me is the highlight. Up-close: not worth the price it’s going these days on ebay.
-EFX Thor Hammer from Avengers Assemble:
This is a beautiful piece but I don't like the handle color on this one nor the angle the strap comes connected with the hammer in (the strap cannot hang down, it's positioned in a way where it always stands). The bright leather is distracting compared to the other versions from the other films which have a darker leather handle (much more fitting IMHO). I would have been happier with a darker leather like the first THOR movie hammer or the DARK WORLD/AGE OF ULTRON version. Having said that, this is the best hammer head. Some will complain that it is not real metal: yes that's true, and I always have the fear that I might bump or drop or scratch it somewhere which could damage the paint job (as this is mirror paint)... But... If you are extra careful and care about a nice hammer head, this is the one you want. Too bad about the handle though. The price it’s going for these days is high, but if you don’t mind the handle color and the way the strap stands , then this is the hammer you want.
-King Arts Thor Hammer from Avengers Age of Ultron/Thor the Dark World:
Now I was torn between getting this one or the CATTOYS or the BEAST KINGDOM version of the same hammer.
I did some research and found out (like the rest of you) that the Beast Kingdom does NOT have a leather handle…it’s apparently painted. Also found some reviews on the CATTOYS that said the handle was leather and others who said the handle was NOT leather. Too much inconsistency… Didn’t want to take a risk on this and get surprised or disappointed. All signs pointed to the KING ARTS version. An online reviewer from the UK did a nice review on youtube and he said the handle was leather with a metal hammer head and he seemed happy with the overall result which encouraged me further so I took a leap of faith with this.
Note: The hammer comes with an IRON MAN gauntlet which I personally didn’t like as it is made of soft plastic.
So it finally arrived and I have to say this King Arts hammer is interesting, the handle is real leather (and the strap too ofcourse)
The head is made of not too shiny actual metal and overall the hammer is HEAVY..the heaviest of the 3 I own. However the main 'critiques' is that the hammer head is a bit dull looking... and if you knock on it, it gives off a slightly hollow sound….This might not bother others but it sort of bothers me when compared to the Museum Replicas and EFX hammer which have more solid/full from the inside hammer heads. I repeat: a slightly hollow sound.
Comparing the shine to the EFX hammer’s paint job leaves something to be desired here.
So that’s the comparisons for you!
Meanwhile:
I read online that Pannaus Props make a nice Thor hammer with a very well designed and detailed hammer head with leather handle design of the Dark World/Age of Ulton .. so I placed an order and currently waiting for it... Will this finally tick all the boxes!??!?! Time will tell!
I will update you guys as soon as I get that one.
If any of you have found a custom shop that makes the original Thor movie hammer design (similar to the Museum Replicas) but with a proper leather handle and a detailed/faithful and properly finished hammer head please let me know.
Thanks!
I am obsessed with the Thor films and the concept of Thor's hammer..etc.
This is what I currently own and my critiques for each in case anyone wants a true comparison of the higher end 'licensed' models out there:
-Museum Replicas/Sideshow Thor Hammer from the first movie:
This one looks great from a distance and a nice piece to have in your living room. As long as nobody comes too close to it…which believe me is unavoidable... Now: up-close once you check the runes/finishing of the hammer head: the lousy work done on the details and poor craftsmanship is visible and a true shame. This hammer's movie design is significant cause it's the original we all saw in the first movie... from the ending of Iron Man 2 and the first THOR movie when people were trying to pull it off the ground... Epic... It's a damn shame that the Museum Replicas guys didn't put the right effort here... seriously poor and rushed overall job. But like I said: from a distance is looks good... up-close: tragically bad. Features: Real metal head, real leather handle and strap. But the metal used for the head is just overall bad... The lines are not straight, the details are blurry and messed up... Overall shame. But I repeat: from FAR it looks amazing especially the way it looks when placed in the original stand it comes with. The stand for me is the highlight. Up-close: not worth the price it’s going these days on ebay.
-EFX Thor Hammer from Avengers Assemble:
This is a beautiful piece but I don't like the handle color on this one nor the angle the strap comes connected with the hammer in (the strap cannot hang down, it's positioned in a way where it always stands). The bright leather is distracting compared to the other versions from the other films which have a darker leather handle (much more fitting IMHO). I would have been happier with a darker leather like the first THOR movie hammer or the DARK WORLD/AGE OF ULTRON version. Having said that, this is the best hammer head. Some will complain that it is not real metal: yes that's true, and I always have the fear that I might bump or drop or scratch it somewhere which could damage the paint job (as this is mirror paint)... But... If you are extra careful and care about a nice hammer head, this is the one you want. Too bad about the handle though. The price it’s going for these days is high, but if you don’t mind the handle color and the way the strap stands , then this is the hammer you want.
-King Arts Thor Hammer from Avengers Age of Ultron/Thor the Dark World:
Now I was torn between getting this one or the CATTOYS or the BEAST KINGDOM version of the same hammer.
I did some research and found out (like the rest of you) that the Beast Kingdom does NOT have a leather handle…it’s apparently painted. Also found some reviews on the CATTOYS that said the handle was leather and others who said the handle was NOT leather. Too much inconsistency… Didn’t want to take a risk on this and get surprised or disappointed. All signs pointed to the KING ARTS version. An online reviewer from the UK did a nice review on youtube and he said the handle was leather with a metal hammer head and he seemed happy with the overall result which encouraged me further so I took a leap of faith with this.
Note: The hammer comes with an IRON MAN gauntlet which I personally didn’t like as it is made of soft plastic.
So it finally arrived and I have to say this King Arts hammer is interesting, the handle is real leather (and the strap too ofcourse)
The head is made of not too shiny actual metal and overall the hammer is HEAVY..the heaviest of the 3 I own. However the main 'critiques' is that the hammer head is a bit dull looking... and if you knock on it, it gives off a slightly hollow sound….This might not bother others but it sort of bothers me when compared to the Museum Replicas and EFX hammer which have more solid/full from the inside hammer heads. I repeat: a slightly hollow sound.
Comparing the shine to the EFX hammer’s paint job leaves something to be desired here.
So that’s the comparisons for you!
Meanwhile:
I read online that Pannaus Props make a nice Thor hammer with a very well designed and detailed hammer head with leather handle design of the Dark World/Age of Ulton .. so I placed an order and currently waiting for it... Will this finally tick all the boxes!??!?! Time will tell!
I will update you guys as soon as I get that one.
If any of you have found a custom shop that makes the original Thor movie hammer design (similar to the Museum Replicas) but with a proper leather handle and a detailed/faithful and properly finished hammer head please let me know.
Thanks!
Similar threads
