I think we're on the same page! Though I can totally understand why some people like matturibe1 don't like it. P1 & Blitzway didn't play it safe and therefore it's only natural the piece would be more divisive. I think it's either you love it or you don't, but thankfully we have lots of options so hopefully everyone can get something they're happy with.
IMO all 3 are solid representations, though the JND is way out of my price range (the P1 is already pushing it), and I feel like I wouldn't be satisfied with the QS knowing there is a version out there with rooted hair that I missed out on.
I definitely like the base with the P1 most as it has way more going on in a good way. I also dig the pose with the P1 as I think it captures the hunched over, deranged nature of Ledger's Joker and I think holding up the card with the knife out is my favorite pose of the 3 too. In all the years I've had Ledger Joker's, that seems to be one of the poses I go with most when it comes to figures.
When I first saw this thing, I thought the portrait looked incredible in execution but I wasn't sure if it captured the essence of Ledger's Joker like they were trying too. But I have definitely come around on it more and I think the expression adds another layer of realism and character to the piece; definitely more unique as far as Ledger Joker's go. Not to mention the hair looks phenomenal for not being rooted hair.