Rank the LOTR/Hobbit films

[FrodoEyes]

I think you apreciate the ents more if you've read the book. I do agree though that they took too long in deciding to fight Saruman.

The first half of TTT actually covers alot of the book. After that they pad the book out a bit with the inclusion of the wargs, Osgiliath, and even Helms Deep, which was a very rushed battle in the book but gets a massive build-up in the movie.

 

[blue_rogue]

1. Fotr
2. Rotk
3. Ttt
4. Auj

 

[IrishJedi]

1. FOTR Theatrical Edition
2. ROTK Theatrical Edition
3. ROTK EE
4. FOTR EE
5. TTT EE
6. TTT Theatrical
7. The Hobbit: AUJ

 

[DPrime]

We need a poll with this too Khev. Come on Now!

FOTR EE
ROTK EE
TTT EE
The Hobbit: AUJ

I'm probably this, although I might actually enjoy The Hobbit more than Two Towers...