Rate SR.

[Seth Gecko]

10 Being epic!!
I give it a 7 good movie enjoyed it...not great but good.
(i know it's a little late but i was wondering now that the movie has been out a while what y'all think about it now)

 

[PosterBoyKelly]

4. Routh and the action were great. The overall plot and a return to a "Hackman" Luthor brought it waaayy down for me though. I was hoping for, ya know, a comic book based Luthor. But I blame the director for it all.

 

[My Lord]

Likewise thought it was about a 7. Really liked it, but of course if could have been better. It was a bit slow in the beginning, but that is to be expected when reinventing a movie franchise.

Brandon Routh is a great Superman, and thought the rest of the cast was very good, EXCEPT for Kate Bosworth. She barely looks to be 21, and thought her performance was severely lacking.

 

[nash]

I gave it a 10. even without an action packed fight sequence, it was still "epic" in my eyes.

 

[Seth Gecko]

I gave it a 10. even without an action packed fight sequence, it was still "epic" in my eyes.

The next one will!!

(It was almost epic for me,but i still had a good time at the theater.And i still watch it on DVD but the replay value kills the final score for me.I love watching the intro more and more thoughLOVE THAT SPACE **** )

 

[Ven]

yeah it was pretty epic to me too.

 

[nash]

I have it on Bluray and it's a gorgeous film. I absolutely love the cinematography of it.

The whole airplane sequence makes up for any lack of fight scenes imo. Just an unparralelled scene that blows me away everytime I watch it. Not to mention it incorporates CK ripping off his shirt to expose the supersuit for the first time in decades.

 

[TheObsoleteMan]

9 for me.

A very sentimental look at the type of hero you just don't see anymore in these jaded times. The scene of Superman hovering above the Earth with the Jor-El voice over gives me chills every time.

 

[Seth Gecko]

I have it on Bluray and it's a gorgeous film. I absolutely love the cinematography of it.

I'll be watching it for the first time in HD when the blu-ray disc gets here tues.

 

[Rugby1970]

I was incredibly disappointed by Superman Returns. I saw it in the theaters and tried to give it another try on BluRay but turned it off after 15 minutes.

They set up a great question "Does the Earth Need A Superman?" but they never really answered it. Why did they never get into Lois article?

Kevin Spacey was a huge disappointment and really brought nothing to the table.

The whole thing felt stiff and lifeless as opposed to having any real life. It felt like a dress rehearsal or a rough draft as opposed to a real movie - interesting ideas but I wish they would have grabbed one and followed it.

Brandon was quite good though and would love to see him get another shot under different circumstances.

 

[King Darkness]

I would give it a 5. Not awful, not great. Just ok.

 

[Spenser]

I was hoping for something much more than a remake of the first Reeve movie. I couldn’t believe they use the same plot and a lot of the same dialog from the first movie. Instead of being original they went with a safe money maker tying to cash in on nostalgia.

And all the pining over Lois and having Superman spying on her home life, It seemed like a bad love sick teen movie.

However I did like the cast, I hope they get to do a more original plot next time.

 

[Ven]

I like the imagery of the movie...


I especially loved the scenes were superman is contempating in space, or hearing the voice of his dead father speak to him in his mind.

 

[Rockabilly]

I gave it a 9, I really enjoyed the film. I thought the lack of a ton of action scenes was slightly disapointing. I understand they needed to tell the story of him leaving and coming back, as well as some of the stuff that happend while he was gone.

I absolutely cannot wait for the next and hope they introduce a new villian that can give Supes a tough fight without the use of kryptonite.

 

[carbo-fation]

I gave it a 9. I loved the movie and I thought Singer did a great job. I only wish there was more action in terms of Superman pounding the crap out of someone.... Still liked it though....much better than X3 or Spidy 3.

 

[Ven]

9 for me.

A very sentimental look at the type of hero you just don't see anymore in these jaded times. The scene of Superman hovering above the Earth with the Jor-El voice over gives me chills every time.

ditto.

 

[Batty]

I give it a seven. It was very solid, but had room for improvement. I though Routh was excellent as Superman. He gets a 10. As do the HT figures.

And yes, a very topical poll.

 

[dekadentdave]

I was incredibly disappointed by Superman Returns. I saw it in the theaters and tried to give it another try on BluRay but turned it off after 15 minutes.

They set up a great question "Does the Earth Need A Superman?" but they never really answered it. Why did they never get into Lois article?

Kevin Spacey was a huge disappointment and really brought nothing to the table.

The whole thing felt stiff and lifeless as opposed to having any real life. It felt like a dress rehearsal or a rough draft as opposed to a real movie - interesting ideas but I wish they would have grabbed one and followed it.

Brandon was quite good though and would love to see him get another shot under different circumstances.

That "S" on his chest is for SUCKS.

 

[customizerwannabe]

Gave it a 4. Couldn't stand Spacey as Luthor. Can't we ever get away from camp with that character??

 

[Kabukiman]

A solid 8 from me. A great setup for the sequel we're all hoping for.