Python
Super Freak
Isn't that exactly what it wasn't? I loved Dredd, many did it seems.
Robocop (2014)
- Thread starter shiveringmelody
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
Isn't that exactly what it wasn't? I loved Dredd, many did it seems.
fosing
Super Freak
moldy bread > robo 2014 > dog p0op
Apparently not. Word of mouth clearly did nothing for it.
Python
Super Freak
Well actually it has, the studio cancelled the sequel which is now looking likely again thanks to the fan base pushing for it.
franpincho
lol@$300 head sculpts
You are right in that regard. DVD/BD sales were very strong though. A shame not enough people went to the theaters.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Wait, so DREDD is bad because it's actually a good adaptation of the comic book...
And because it felt like 80s flick with its simplicity and violence...
And because RoboCop concept is a ripoff of Dredd...
Either I see things that aren't in your posts or you finally lost it
thenammagazine
Super Freak
Wait, so DREDD is bad because it's actually a good adaptation of the comic book...
And because it felt like 80s flick with its simplicity and violence...
And because RoboCop concept is a ripoff of Dredd...
Either I see things that aren't in your posts or you finally lost it
Dredd is bad because Khev doesn't like people poopooing this new RoboCop he loves more than the original.
The CG blood *killed* the 80's vibe. Just killed it. Didn't feel 80's at all. And classic 80's action flicks were actually quite clever, which Dredd also was not.
Python
Super Freak
Your comparing it to the new robocop and your complaining about bad CGI?
At least the new Robocop knew enough to cut away from bloodshed than to show that fake video game crap. Some things just have to be CGI and it'll either look real or it won't. There's no excuse for not using real squibs.
Python
Super Freak
I honestly don't understand. I am a stickler for bad cgi, it drives me mad, I also hate 3d so Dredd should have been on my naughty list, it turns out however it was great. I didn't notice any bad cgi, I thought it was incredibly well integrated and very minimal actually and watching it in 2d had no averse effects, noting noticeably flew at the screen. I'll stop arguing now, we clearly won't agree. I'll stick to Dredd and the original rated R for Robocop
ExMem-LarjaThwei
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2010
- Messages
- 10,762
- Reaction score
- 18
I thought those slo-mo blood-splatter scenes in Dredd were supposed to be exaggerated and video gameish.
I honestly don't understand. I am a stickler for bad cgi, it drives me mad, I also hate 3d so Dredd should have been on my naughty list, it turns out however it was great. I didn't notice any bad cgi, I thought it was incredibly well integrated and very minimal actually and watching it in 2d had no averse effects, noting noticeably flew at the screen. I'll stop arguing now, we clearly won't agree. I'll stick to Dredd and the original rated R for Robocop
Maybe the cartoon blood translated well to 3D, I wouldn't know as I watched it in 2D. All I noticed was that it looked worse than the blood I'd seen in every other action move ever made and was totally distracting. I suppose I might have let it slide if like it's 80's counterparts (Robocop, Die Hard, etc.) it was interesting, clever, or inspired, but it was just such a generic door to door shoot 'em up it had no impact on me whatsoever. At least Robo 2014 had the Murphy parts reveal, better than anything in Dredd.
But I hear you, agree to disagree.
Python
Super Freak
I watched Dredd in 2d also, I meant it didn't feel like any 3d parts were being forced on you.
I will say this, Dredd had a good tone. In that sense it was a nice palette cleanser after Stallone. Urban was also cool as hell and looked great in the suit. I just wish they'd made a better movie with what they had. The villain sucked. If this movie had a Hans Gruber or a **** Jones or a Clarence Boddicker it might have been something. Unfortunately that wasn't the case.
I guess I can be a fence-sitter by being open to sequels for both Dredd and the new Robocop.
Dredd definitely had potential. I'd be up for Urban and his partner returning for another outing.
Your comparing it to the new robocop and your complaining about bad CGI?
desperation makes the man blind.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Dredd > RC 2014
Not even close really.
Dredd entirely great.
RC 2014 some good parts and many forgettable parts.
Not even close really.
Dredd entirely great.
RC 2014 some good parts and many forgettable parts.
I'd really like to know what makes Dredd 2012 "great." I'm guessing I won't get any specifics.
Similar threads
