Is ZyuRanger the most popular Power Ranger series out there? (It's arguably the most recognized Ranger series because of its importation to American audiences as the first ranger show). Do Japanese audiences think it's any good? Is another ranger series even more popular in Japan?
ZyuRanger was not a fan favorite. What people don't realize is Sentai in Japan has been around for years, decades even since the 70's hence the 37th anniversary.
What does that mean. Nothing really for them to get excited about because ever since Goranger was born, there have been a Sentai Series every single year to this day and still coming out every year. A Sentai series has to really be memorable and elite for the fans to have a following in Japan, otherwise they're used to seeing a series all the time for tv.
I heard that Gokaiger has a strong fanbase following among the japanese, probably because it broke the traditional mold of the rangers being good and helping the earth. Whereas the Kaigers are pirates who only care about treasure and their own personal issues. They also pay homage to the Goranger history and culture as well.
Shinkenger because of the Samurai theme as well.
If PR started in the states around the 70's I'm sure the U.S. would treat it the same way as the japanese do. It made an impact in the states because there was nothing like it before by then. The idea of rangers was new and a fresh idea to the U.S.
For the Japanese the idea of Sentai is just a everyday drama they are used to watching. Since viewing Sentai is automatic in Japan, the second would be the story line or plots that excite them. Zyuranger was more of a story arc towards kiddies because of the dinosaur theme and extreme involvement of children in the episodes. It didn't win over the older fans of sentai too well.
Now to answer the question once more. Zyuranger wasn't that popular in Japan.
To be honest, Kamen Rider has a huge following in Japan, more than Sentai at times. The Japanese love the Kamen Rider franchise. Ultra man is another identity that Japan absolutely admires and never gets sick of as well.
I know the U.S. has tried to do both Kamen Rider and Ultra man ideas and have failed.
I would have to believe if they attempted to bring back Kamen Rider and do it right in the states, I'm sure the franchise will be an instant classic.