Saga Madness: Round One - ROTJ vs TPM

[MaulFan]

As much a fan of the PT as I am, we never got Padme in a skimpy bikini, and while at times Carrie wasn't a super hotty, Jabba's Palace was a fanboys dream

 

[The Josh]

As much a fan of the PT as I am, we never got Padme in a skimpy bikini, and while at times Carrie wasn't a super hotty, Jabba's Palace was a fanboys dream

Yeah, she was pretty hot in that part.

 

[MaulFan]

It's a shame we didn't get Natalie like that, c'mon Lucas, where was the Leia and Luke conception scene when we needed it!!!

 

[The Josh]

It's a shame we didn't get Natalie like that, c'mon Lucas, where was the Leia and Luke conception scene when we needed it!!!

I know. Such a shame really.

 

[MaulFan]

I still remember watching TPM the first time in the theater, the scene where she's alone with Ani in Watto's shop, I thought Natalie was the most beautiful actress I'd ever seen at the moment, and still do to this day.

 

[bonsey]

Jedi..no comparison.
Can't even watch those first two prequels all the way through anymore.

 

[Darth Loki]

I still remember watching TPM the first time in the theater, the scene where she's alone with Ani in Watto's shop, I thought Natalie was the most beautiful actress I'd ever seen at the moment, and still do to this day.

Back off my b!tch mother f@cker!!!

I had been obsessed with her long before SW. Now I just had a reasont to watch movies with her over and over again

 

[Lord Aykroyd]

ROTJ - even with the ewoks

 

[carbo-fation]

ROTJ....my favorite!

 

[NASEDO]

Phantom Menace has to be the worst of all 6. Jar Jar Binks and bad acting by Padme kill the whole movie.

 

[The Josh]

Back off my b!tch mother f@cker!!!

I had been obsessed with her long before SW. Now I just had a reasont to watch movies with her over and over again

Yeah, I liked her before SW as well. She ranks among my top beauties list.

 

[MaulFan]

I never knew of her before Star Wars, it's weird, I can't even remember really what movies I was into back then, I was 14 when TPM came out, I was mainly into like Rambo and Terminator movies at the time, so I had no idea bout Leon, and I never saw Heat until a few months ago, otherwise I'm sure I'd have had a crush on her back then.

 

[The Josh]

I was 18 when the TPM came out in 1999.

 

[MaulFan]

Scratch that, I was actually 15-16 when it first came out now that I think of it, I was 15 in May when it was released and turned 16 in July, I was in London 2 days before the London premiere, I was so bummed, I would have loved to catch them all in person like that, would have been a once in a life time memory.

 

[PosterBoyKelly]

ROTJ is my fav. ever, and I know it won't win, BUT I will vote for it till the end. Best scene ever, Luke vs. Vader w/ Palpatine, the emotion is higher than any of the 6! "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO" :::Lightsaber beat down::::emperor

 

[JAWS]

Musically, that's my favorite piece in the entire saga, it was just so powerful, so beautiful, but too short . After that, I'd say Battle of the Heroes and the variations on the notes used in the ROTS duel, again, powerful and beautiful music there. A Star Wars box set was the first cds I ever owned and I was so thrilled to be able to listen to Star Wars music, I actually would just play the Luke defeats Vader music over and over again, it just touches my soul every time I hear it.

The Star Wars Boxed set was the first CDs I ever owned also. I was so happy to finally have the Luke defeats Vader music.

It says everything about the scene. Luke toying with the darkside, fighting his father like he does not want to. The sadness, threat, and finality of it all. Just a perfect piece of music for that scene.

That scene and Vader turning to the good side really make the movie for me.

 

[PosterBoyKelly]

That scene and Vader turning to the good side really make the movie for me.

That scene really makes the SAGA to me! It's just the best, every emotion, everything soooo much more dire than anything in all of the others, ti all comes down to this!:emperor

 

[swabie2424]

Jedi.

Oh and I'll save time too... ESB over ROTS!

OT is soooo much better than PT it is scary.

 

[elwood49]

Incidentally, it is also the first film I ever really remember seeing in the theatre.

Me too. We must be about the same age (27).

 

[LOTRFan]

Me too. We must be about the same age (27).

Indeed, I will be 28 in June.