As a modern game, it deserves the poor reviews. Set against the standards of modern games, and their control layouts and fluidity...it just doesn't stack up. However, if you go in with a certain mindset, you can enjoy it. For instance, I consider myself a veteran of the Survival Horror genre, and I play classic RE games regularly. Comparatively, the controls are as "bad" as those games. I say bad because that's usually a major complaint on those games from a modern perspective. To me though, they're almost second nature. So contrast it with classic games instead of modern games. Use a similar mindset, and you may like it. If not, it's completely understandable.
The story is actually pretty good. The environments have great atmosphere and there's definitely some genuine disturbing moments and great game events. It is slow and sometimes tough to get through. but I liked it better than Homecoming.
I love old school Survival Horror and I've been into the genre probably just as long as you and as long as the genre has been around.
I might pick it up at some point, I passed on Homecoming since a lot of people hated it.
Pyramid Head is in it right? Not just that secret ending?