Star Wars Defining Moments

[ironwez20]

The best scene in the entire Star Wars saga is Vader's wrath at the end of Rogue One. And I want you all to know that I'd take the Battle of Scarif over the Battle of Endor every day of the week and twice on Sunday.

I’m sorry I find ur name very intriguing.

 

[Prime Clone]

Vader's epic scene at the end of Rogue One is the result of the cinematographer's "interference" not the studios! Please do your homework boy.

Sorry, assumption on my part. I was under the impression LFL/Disney wanted "more Vader".

 

[The Autistic Asexual]

Sorry, assumption on my part. I was under the impression LFL/Disney wanted "more Vader".

Vader's brief appearances in Rogue One is the most brilliant, masterful example of 'less is more' that I have ever witnessed.

 

[Otomofan]

i thought it was unnecessarily cruel, violent, graphic, and gratuitous personally.....but to each their own.

 

[The Autistic Asexual]

I’m sorry I find ur name very intriguing.

Kind of a funny one isn't it? Even though I'm a grown man who should never be allowed to have any kind of child-like joy because that's what society dictates I just refuse to grow up in certain areas. I can look at and marvel at how awesomely detailed and cool action figures of today are like an autistic 'tard. And also intercourse and the many diseases thereof freaks me out. Call me odd I guess.

 

[The Autistic Asexual]

i thought it was unnecessarily cruel, violent, graphic, and gratuitous personally.....but to each their own.

How is Vader's big scene in Rogue One gratuitous? Or are you just being a troll?

 

[a-dev]

Kind of a funny one isn't it? Even though I'm a grown man who should never be allowed to have any kind of child-like joy because that's what society dictates I just refuse to grow up in certain areas. I can look at and marvel at how awesomely detailed and cool action figures of today are like an autistic 'tard. And also intercourse and the many diseases thereof freaks me out. Call me odd I guess.

Sometimes I wish I was asexual. I think I'd be a lot more productive in my life.

 

[Khev]

Sometimes I wish I was asexual.

"I'll take 'Announcements I didn't expect a-dev to make today' for 500 Alex," lol.

 

[a-dev]

Not something I was looking to say or anything.

 

[Otomofan]

How is Vader's big scene in Rogue One gratuitous? Or are you just being a troll?

Not trolling at all. It was just straight up murder porn. We the audience get an almost orgasmic rush watching Vader slaughter desperate men that had no fighting chance to survive. They were crapping their pants in terror of him and he slaughtered them all like animals. It was something I could always imagine as part of the lore but never had any desire to see. I thought it was way over the top, way too brutal, and having way too much fun with the pointless deaths of dozens of men. I found it more nauseating and sad than "fun" and "thrilling.'

 

[The Autistic Asexual]

Sometimes I wish I was asexual. I think I'd be a lot more productive in my life.

You would have a lot less of a carbon footprint which is a lot better for the planet that's for sure.

 

[The Autistic Asexual]

Not trolling at all. It was just straight up murder porn. We the audience get an almost orgasmic rush watching Vader slaughter desperate men that had no fighting chance to survive. They were crapping their pants in terror of him and he slaughtered them all like animals. It was something I could always imagine as part of the lore but never had any desire to see. I thought it was way over the top, way too brutal, and having way too much fun with the pointless deaths of dozens of men. I found it more nauseating and sad than "fun" and "thrilling.'

LMMFAO Are you 4?

 

[Prime Clone]

Vader was always scary because of what you imagined he’d do, not what you saw him do. As with Bruce the shark, it was the menace that was scary rather than the actual violence.

But RO just continues the modern trend of everything needing to be spelt out/shown.

And the Vader scene was contrived - it didn’t fit with ANH’s mention of transmissions being “beamed” to the ship.

 

[Khev]

Not something I was looking to say or anything.

 

[Ehollywood]

Still my fave space battle out of all the Star Wars films.

 

[The Autistic Asexual]

Vader was always scary because of what you imagined he’d do, not what you saw him do. As with Bruce the shark, it was the menace that was scary rather than the actual violence.

But RO just continues the modern trend of everything needing to be spelt out/shown.

And the Vader scene was contrived - it didn’t fit with ANH’s mention of transmissions being “beamed” to the ship.

The Vader scene did not mess with the beginning of A New Hope at all. Plus in the original movie after Vader talks about how plans were "beamed to the ship" an Imperial Officer tells him that no transmissions were made aboard said ship.

 

[DiFabio]

The Vader scene did not mess with the beginning of A New Hope at all. Plus in the original movie after Vader talks about how plans were "beamed to the ship" an Imperial Officer tells him that no transmissions were made aboard said ship.

The real 1970s/1980s Vader wouldn’t have done what he did at the end of RO. He would have just sent in his Stormtroopers first, like he did on the Tantive IV and Echo Base at Hoth.

All that lightsaber twirling, slashing and force spamming he does is Prequel/video game tier. It was over the top and stupid.


Also, why does Vader act like such a primadonna in this scene?




His erratic movement as Krennic is talking, the way he throws his head back and getting all flippant and saucy. He’s acting like a teenage girl. Speaking of transmissions, couldn’t Krennic have just instant messaged Vader? Imagine how long it takes Vader to get dressed. Krennic interrupted him for that?

Vader’s scenes are dumb in that movie.

 

[a-dev]

You do have a point....but I don't care. It was too cool not to like. Needless to say I also don't share Otomofan's reaction to it.

 

[Chakor]

The real 1970s/1980s Vader wouldn’t have done what he did at the end of RO. He would have just sent in his Stormtroopers first, like he did on the Tantive IV and Echo Base at Hoth.

All that lightsaber twirling, slashing and force spamming he does is Prequel/video game tier. It was over the top and stupid.


Also, why does Vader act like such a primadonna in this scene?




His erratic movement as Krennic is talking, the way he throws his head back and getting all flippant and saucy. He’s acting like a teenage girl. Speaking of transmissions, couldn’t Krennic have just instant messaged Vader? Imagine how long it takes Vader to get dressed. Krennic interrupted him for that?

Vader’s scenes are dumb in that movie.

 

[DiFabio]