Star Wars Rebels Coming Fall 2014

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
that last episode was bad... just bad.. for an adult to watch....
 
Really? It's on tomorrow here, I'll not set my hopes too high. I guess the clone wars started off a bit more child friendly than it ultimately ended up being however so there is hope. The foundation is there.

One thing I will say though, the clone wars had some excellent starship designs. I'm not seeing that in rebels at all yet.
 
One thing I will say though, the clone wars had some excellent starship designs. I'm not seeing that in rebels at all yet.

I agree. Great starship designs throughout CW and most of them original. With Rebels, I get the nod to McQuarrie's vision and trying to blend it into the beginning of SW, but you can't use concept art for every single design.
 
I'm only just the right side of 30 and I enjoyed this episode also. It's nice to see the clones again, and it was actually quite touching towards the end.


I agree. Great starship designs throughout CW and most of them original. With Rebels, I get the nod to McQuarrie's vision and trying to blend it into the beginning of SW, but you can't use concept art for every single design.


Yeah, they did a lot right with that show. I guess there is still plenty of time for Rebels to catch up and improve in certain areas however. Vehicle deign being one such area I'd love to see some more imagination.
 
I think I'd go as far as to say that was my favorite episode of Rebels so far..

It was a good episode, but the season 1 finale was by far the best episode of the show. Of course is just my opinion! :)
 
I will say that Rebels is not as adult orientated as Clone Wars was especially in Clone Wars later seasons. That said I think this second season of Rebels so far is a lot better then the first season, I've really enjoyed it so far. They defiantly have made a bit more of an effort to make it more adult friendly to watch where the first season felt like it was a bit to kid friendly. I'm still grimacing over the whole gun/lightsaber....

It was cool to see Rex again.... I just wish they would use Asoka more even though I know she is just a supporting role character in Rebels vs a Main character in Clone Wars...
 
Reasons why I think this episode was bad...

1.just send down some Tie fighters and bomb them down..why going through the hustle with those slow AT-ATs....this was feeling so forced to show AT-AT at the show
2. they talk about scanners in orbit but no scanners to find them in the sandstorm ?
3. Same with the Cat and mouse play in the storm.. didnt felt realistic to me at all.

To sum it up.. to me it was clearly a kids episode..what is fine with me. But season opener and season 1 finale are the best so far.. I hope its not dropping now in excitement because thats whats happening to me right now
 
They mentioned that scanners don't work properly in the storm. As for realism, well this is a cartoon version of a franchise that built two (maybe three) moon sized space stations. Realism isn't a factor I use to judge it on. The episode was enjoyable imo, but everyone is different.

Forcing elements to add to the entertainment is nothing new... Starship Troopers wouldn't exist without such liberties as the fleet would have blasted the bugs from space. Pacific Rim would be a very short movie as a few A-10's made short work of each Kaiju without the need for giant robots... Etc etc etc.
 
Reasons why I think this episode was bad...

1.just send down some Tie fighters and bomb them down..why going through the hustle with those slow AT-ATs....this was feeling so forced to show AT-AT at the show
2. they talk about scanners in orbit but no scanners to find them in the sandstorm ?
3. Same with the Cat and mouse play in the storm.. didnt felt realistic to me at all.

To sum it up.. to me it was clearly a kids episode..what is fine with me. But season opener and season 1 finale are the best so far.. I hope its not dropping now in excitement because thats whats happening to me right now

All valid reasons to be bugged. Me, I just have fun. I don't try to analyze things too deeply (not that there is anything wrong with that).
 
So it's got to be obvious that they will do what CW did and start shoehorning boba fett and maul and cad bane into these seasons. Maybe one big bad per season like how CW had boba end out season 2, savage in 3, maul in 4, etc

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
So it's got to be obvious that they will do what CW did and start shoehorning boba fett and maul and cad bane into these seasons. Maybe one big bad per season like how CW had boba end out season 2, savage in 3, maul in 4, etc

As long as we get this actual episode, I'll be happy.

 
All valid reasons to be bugged. Me, I just have fun. I don't try to analyze things too deeply (not that there is anything wrong with that).

100%....I just plain enjoy them...just because its Star Wars....bottom line...having fun with the fantasy called Star Wars...
 
Back
Top