TFA is a product of the social media/ad driven environment where it became an event like the Super Bowl. Wrongly calculated sales numbers due to increase prices in movie tickets doesn't capture any magic. Those box office numbers Khev was so enthusiastic for are completely wrong. TFA was not the most watched movie of all time... it just made the most money. When calculating for inflation.... it still isn't number one in that regard.
A lot of people who saw Star Wars barely are fans, just like those who watch the Super Bowl..... it was a event that captured the country so those could go post on there social media outlets "I saw Star Wars (insert emoji here)." Or to simply say they watched it and have the small talk/water cooler conversations. Just as it is "cool" to watch the Super Bowl.... it was cool to go see TFA with the growing acceptance of the "nerd culture."
Star War, just as the Super Bowl, has transcended American culture.
Although I wasn't alive or experienced it, I would say walking into the theaters in May 1977 to see Star Wars would have been the peak of this "magic" you talk about. The world was different back then. I think it meant more for a relatively unknown new movie to do so well in the 70s without the current cultural parameters influencing it.
I don't think anything can capture the "magic" from the original because of how Star Wars is perceived today.
And yet I couldn't care less about what Star Wars is today.
I just want to watch a well though film. "Da Farce Awakens" wasn't even close to that.
Heck, most people couldn't care less about the content of films but producers keep makin' these "by the numbers" vomits.