That's because HT Batman came pretty much at the peak of their lesser figures. HT has set a bar, but their best stuff has only come over the last year, 2 years. If you compare their early Rambos to the current ones, you can see leaps and bounds of improvement in the sculpts, and I think the sculpt is the primary point where people aren't fans of the HT Bats, and from pictures I've seen, I'd aggree. Even though I have this figure coming, I am curious to see what HT does with Batman this time around, if they even go for the license, because a Bale head and Batman head with their skin texturing and all would be quite something.