**No spoilers**
Well, I saw it. And I loved it. Quality-wise probably a 7/10 or so. About a second tier MCU film, like Captain America: The First Avenger or Thor 1.
But for me it hit the right notes. I even teared up. Twice. No joke. This movie has some real sentimentality to it regarding Pops and Sarah and a thinly veiled commentary on Arnold being an "obsolete" action hero from a "timeline that no longer exists." It was tough to see him playing that when it obviously parallels his own persona. Raptors never age, and superheroes will always be rebooted with "younger models" but for a lifelong Arnold fan I couldn't help but root for him.
Let me say this, there ARE still some genuine surprises with regard to the story. Well I stopped watching clips and TV spots about a month ago so I guess more things could have been spoiled but I was happy to be surprised by a twist or two that I hadn't seen in the trailers.
Evil John was cool, but again, he felt more like an MCU villain. Not on the level of 84 Arnold or the T-1000 but he can certainly hang with Ultron.
The future prologue was AWESOME. I feel like I actually got to see that unfilmed T2 prologue where they storm the compound, find the time displacement equipment, and, well you know the rest. And that photobombing idiot from Entertainment Weekly definitely got an upgrade because I thought the finished Endos were bad ass.
Courtney was okay, definitely a different Reese. Almost more of a John McClane Reese with his attitude and one-liners.
But Clarke. She was a freaking angel. Seriously, I just pretty much wanted to jump into the movie and rescue her the whole time. Give me a whole trilogy about her and Pops. She's the "Tom Hardy" of Sarah Connors. So while Reese was a step down I would say she was a step up from Hamilton for me.
The contemporary vehicle action was cool but didn't really take anything "up a notch." The vehicle action was below T2. Well I guess the helicopter chase would have been as good as T2 action if they had used real helicopters. But CG choppers don't really "count" IMO. There was however, an awesome homage to "Commando" that I won't spoil.
Where the action shines is at the beginning in the future and Pops' final duel against Endo John. THAT was awesome and was one kickass visual after another.
So to summarize, I really liked it. A bit below T1 and T2 but far about T3 and TS, just like others have said.
1. Future war was spectacular
2. Clark Sarah was freaking adorable every second she was on screen
3. I liked the chemistry between Pops, Sarah, and Reese
4. Some good, unspoiled twists
5. Timeline hopping was fun
6. Final duel was really cool
I'm really into where they're going with this story and will be quite upset if this is another "one and one" trilogy starter.