The movie NAILS Spider-man in my opinion. This is finally how the character should look like on-screen. The costume is nothing short of perfect and is the BEST comic-to-live-action translation of a costume. Everything about it works. Andrew Garfield is also GREAT in both roles. His Spider-man is humorous, funny yet still gives that "Friendly Neighborhood Spider-man" vibe that grabs an assist from several heart-warming scenes that show Spidey SAVING EVERYDAY PEOPLE. Something that lacks in a lot of superhero movies as of late. You can tell when the graphics are CGI, but the action is so much fun, colorful and dazzling that you feel like you're reading a Spider-man comic. The Web-slinger moves EXACTLY like he goes in the comic books and the film crew does a good job of making sure you can follow the action during the intense CGI scenes with some "slow-mo" parts that I personally liked. There's not too much of the "shaky cam" we've seen in previous films.
Once again, the chemistry between Garfield and Emma Stone is off-the-charts. It helps that they're actually a real-life couple and that translates well on-screen with the scenes between Peter and Gwen. Some reviewers mentioned being confused whether they're together or not and let's just say that if you've ever been in that sort of "limbo" stage in a relationship, that's what they're in...but not in a bad way, more so confused about their lives and their directions. They're high school graduates, so of course any romantic drama is going to be confusing.
The supporting cast is amazing. However, the shoe-horned RHINO scenes and Richard Parker scenes make me wishing they trimmed them or completely cut them from the film to make room for the rest of it. The Richard Parker scene in the beginning was TOO long and I feel they could've cut it in a way which made everyone recognize that Oscorp had a hand in their death. Perhaps show them boarding the plane and the co-pilot conceal his gun or something. Next show the plane crash and that's it. The Rhino scene did well for a "Spidey return" but for a character so heavily marketed, he had a small role and wasn't really overly necessary.
And this is where I think the bulk of the movie should've focused on: Dane Dehaan's Harry Osborn and Jamie Foxx's Electro. Though Electro gets a fair share of the movie, spending a little more time rooting his "over-the-top" nerdy character's angst and insanity would've helped a bit. It's sort of like Jim Carey's Riddler in BATMAN FOREVER. But it's cool because once he becomes Electro, he is 100x more intense. The real shame is that we don't see much of Dehaan's Harry Osborn develop. Because Dehaan's Osborn is MUCH better than James Franco's in my opinion. Dehaan has that underlying evilness and insanity look to him and he performed VERY well in the scenes that he did have. Showing the friction between him and his father would've helped as well (Chris Cooper is in the flick for about two minutes...really?). I also like his GOBLIN much better. It's a character that you can get the PERSONALITY right for (which I think Dehaan did) but comic fans never seem to be satisfied with how he looks.
A lot of this I think is pushed aside because of how fresh this reboot is off the heels of the Raimi trilogy, in which we had THREE movies to see Parker and Osborn form from best friends to hated rivals. So I feel they sort of rushed through all that dynamic because they probably felt audiences are familiar enough with Peter and Harry to know about their friendship. However, in my opinion I would've liked to have seen more because I feel Dehaan is a MUCH BETTER Harry Osborn just as Andrew Garfield is a better Peter Parker/Spider-man.
Overall it's a great movie. Spider-man looks "right" on-screen and looks like he dived right out of the comic books. It's definitely better than Spider-man 3, but has TOO MUCH packed into it's 2+ hrs. time-frame. The good thing is that it isn't snore-worthy and there isn't any ridiculousness that Spider-man 3 had. Webb definitely captured the drama and emotion that you would expect in a Spider-man flick, but giving more time to the MAIN CAST as opposed to book-end characters (Rhino, Richard Parker mostly) could've helped the MEAT of the story and the character development much more.