The Mandalorian (Star Wars Live Action Series)

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Oh, well... the numbers are out and the viewer count has dropped significantly this season.

After the all-time high ending of Season 2, I think the combination of BOBF, OWK, and (unfortunately) Andor, have really taken the wind out of the brands sails. Particularly with the casual viewers.
Weird because the S3 trailer had huge numbers. On the other hand, since people like me are online blabbing when an episode drops, people find out fast enough if an episode is a must see now or not.
 
they need to work on the pacing when they look at the season as a whole.

Episode 1- absolutely nothing of relevance really happens except setting up the exact same storyline for the season that was set up in Mando's episode of BOBF.
Episode 2- pretty fantastic breakneck action which ties up that storyline succinctly, with a startling discovery. a lot happens that is key to the world of the show and the characters.
Episode 3- amazing opening. a truly great star wars dogfight. then the credits hit and we're saddled with 40 minutes which has nothing to do with our protagonist or the quest. nothing to do with the startling discovery at the end. a plot which is pretty obviously heading a certain way the entire time and has a real lack of subtlety- trying to make the new republic seem like idiots thanks of course to jj abrams and rian johnson. after this, we have a cool conclusion...but all i ask is why? im sure the middle is necessary to the plot of the season but it just feels so out of place when we have a cliffhanger from last episode. a cliffhanger that as a viewer, i was immersed in. im interested in din, the discovery, what bo's going to do- but all of that is put on pause this week.

they need to fix the pacing. it is insanely jarring and ruins any push the story has because it seems unbelievably unfocused.

you've got BOBF- you give us mando 2.5
you've got kenobi- you give us the reva show
you've got mando s3- and we have an entire episode focused on this doctor

do they even know why we're here?
 
What a strange episode.

I actually liked it, but I can't see myself ever watching it a second time. It felt like a weird mix of "1984" and "Severance" and even had that creepy "Stranger Things" music.

Ever since AOTC I've always thought Coruscant was a location that needed to be explored in depth. There's limitless possibilities there. Especially when you delve into the lore that poor people live underground and the rich are all in the opulent penthouses in the sky. That would be a really amazing premise for a SW show, as long as it's not dull as dishwater like the Mon Mothma stuff in Andor. While this was bizarrely out of place, this is closer to my "vision" of a Coruscant show.

I still hate hate HATE the fact that this guy wears a regular old pair of eyeglasses though. It sticks out like a sore thumb, like the little fat girl's braces in Phantom Menace.
 
Okay then. Spoiler-y business below:

Opening scene was wildly entertaining, in spite of plot armour and more hamfisted exposition about how tough Interceptors are. (Not tough enough for plot armour).

Comparing this scene to Top Gun: Maverick I have to wonder where Din got the time to train as an elite fighter pilot, but let’s say the N1 is AI-assisted and enhances his well-developed warrior instincts, reflexes and proprioception. Fan-splaining™ at its finest! :lecture

I had high hopes for this episode; Coruscant looked amazing in that first shot and in some subsequent scenes, but I was taken out immediately by poor sound design. I can buy that certain areas/levels will look lonely or deserted at certain times, but the lack of ambient noise was distracting and felt low-budget. Sure you could *say* it’s part of Coruscant’s ‘environmental controls’ but this is film and tv — to sell this place the background hum and roar should have sounded like NYC on steroids.

The Amnesty storyline could have been interesting but it felt like an extremely dumbed down (as in Saturday morning cartoon) rip-off of Andor. I won’t write a wall of text explaining why, I’m sure anyone without their Star Wars goggles on can see it — and to where it’s obviously leading. A lot of cringe all around.

Amongst the bigger plot contrivances: ticket droids can make footbridges appear between train cars but can’t lock down the doors? They also moved very slowly during the ‘pursuit’ which would have only made sense if the doors were lockable.

This is a place where jetpacks and cybernetic enhancements exist, aliens with strange abilities … maybe a few good Parkour athletes as well LOL … give those droids a little speed maybe.

So there’s … zero security in a yard full of decommissioned Imperial tech? Inoperable or not --sure.

Speaking of the Andor rip-off … the eventual fall of the New Republic with trillions of deaths is due to them emulating the soulless, bureaucratic Empire and alienating people that they designate and refer to with SERIAL NUMBERS and perform INVOLUNTARY PROCEDURES on?!

And also because they’re ******* idiots and don’t have security of any kind around sensitive installations? Plus no one actually monitors or safeguards aforementioned INVOLUNTARY PERSONALITY ADJUSTMENTS which are easy to crank up to 11 for nefarious purposes.

This has all happened before, and will all happe — sorry, wrong franchise.

Anyway, at present this show is only good for action candy. The writing is degrading at a rapid pace. Perhaps fitting given where it’s leading to.

Random moments:

Mon Cal’s look when he heard “It was a trap!” LOLOLOL
Bo Katan telling everyone Din fell and had to be pulled out. LOLOL

… and looks like Bo found herself a new army … although the big guy may have something to say about that. How many duels is he gonna lose? Didn't Din already kick his ***? Maybe lay off the space cheeseburgers, bud.
 
thanks for the input, I'm not wasting my time watching it.

penguin-batman-returns.gif
 
Mein Gott, there's just no pleasing some people!

Excellent episode, tying in with Andor and showing the New Republic as not quite the benevolent government we may have thought it would be. This season has so far wrong-footed me into thinking where it was going. Excited to see where it does go.
 
Mein Gott, there's just no pleasing some people!

Excellent episode, tying in with Andor and showing the New Republic as not quite the benevolent government we may have thought it would be. This season has so far wrong-footed me into thinking where it was going. Excited to see where it does go.
It's a mixed bag. :dunno
 
Mein Gott, there's just no pleasing some people!

Excellent episode, tying in with Andor and showing the New Republic as not quite the benevolent government we may have thought it would be. This season has so far wrong-footed me into thinking where it was going. Excited to see where it does go.
I thought folks who really liked Andor might like the middle part. I personally found Andor to be sort of boring (yeah, I know, I have no taste or culture whatsoever).
 
Uuuuuum..... okay.... sure... why not? :unsure:

The other two eps felt like toy commercials and this felt like an ep of Andor.

Not sure what drugs they're all smoking over at Lucasfilm in the last few years, but this is an odd season so far.
 
I thought folks who really liked Andor might like the middle part. I personally found Andor to be sort of boring (yeah, I know, I have no taste or culture whatsoever).
Felt like a different show and not in a good way. So does the rest of the season in fact.

I also dunno why the characters this season are all basically narrating the show, explaining every action they’re doing and choice they make, it’s weird and it makes the entire thing feel dumbed down.
 
Uuuuuum..... okay.... sure... why not? :unsure:

The other two eps felt like toy commercials and this felt like an ep of Andor.

Not sure what drugs they're all smoking over at Lucasfilm in the last few years, but this is an odd season so far.
Just wait until you hear about Book of Boba Fett. Two whole episodes felt like The Mandalorian instead!
 
It’s now so obvious that episodes 5 & 6 of BOBF were intended to be episodes 1 & 2 of Mando season 3. Hence the pacing issues and “filler”. So in order to boost the quality of another show Mando has suffered as a result. That said I quite liked today’s episode, but the season really does feel like it’s yet to take off.
 
I can't imagine how anyone can compare that segment to Andor as an equivalent. It's like Favreau or whoever tried to mimic Andor with crayons on their juice and cookies break. It's a laughably poor copy at best.
I disagree , but find your analogy highly amusing 😂
 
Back
Top