I thought all the BW's came out very well, including the hair.
To each their own; the original needed a lot of help IMO and I fear the same for the short hair on the AOU version.
You might as well mention Barbies if you're going to cherry-pick the worst examples. I don't want bad looking rooted hair any more than I want a bad face sculpt. If rooted is done well, it's excellent. Same goes for male figures too, it's just super hard to do short hair rooted in a realistic fashion because you can't keep the short fibers styled. And when short, sculpted hair isn't an eyesore.
I really wasn't cherry picking to be fair; I honestly couldn't think of another figure that had the two options available, hence why I used it as an example.
So... look at the mods of the latest Thor done up with rooted hair (saw a really nice one on Facebook yesterday - looks amazing. The original looks like garbage, IMO.
Care to share this? I did some Googling and didn't find it; however I found this, and I think we all can have a good laugh regardless.
This could work out to our advantage. One specific hair style, comes pre-styled and braided. Done. Don't undo the work if you don't want it to look like a bomb went off.
Icompletely agree with you here - If the braids are tight enough to hold the hair down, then it might just work out brilliantly. Fingers crossed this is the best and most likely option; again, I'm not denying the superiority of rooted hair past a point, I just have yet to see production figures perfect it yet.
This is like the Selina Kyle thread all over again - though she has straight hair of course. Or even the Chewbacca thread. I wouldn't have bought a sculpted wookie.
I wasn't around the forums yet for Selena Kyle, so I'm exempt there
But I do agree on Chewie, a sculpted look would not have been even remotely appropriate there.
At the end of the day I want an awesome looking head sculpt, including the hair. If they can't get it done with rooted, then by all means, sculpted as a fall-back. But when done right, rooted can have a level of realism just not possible from a sculpt.
I absolutely concur here; but that's a big IF unfortunately. That being said, 3Z has proven to deliver some very detailed and highly weathered pieces so far, perhaps they're the ones to break major ground here.