I'd ignore them and keep it. It's not your fault.
Most companies wouldn't make an *** out of themselves and resort to this. It's not your responsibility, so I'd just ignore their emails. Don't let them make a chump out of you.
Keep it.
On another note, wouldn't it be messed up if the one that was sent out to you is the reason one of the guys above didn't receive theirs lol.
(FTC) is clear on this issue.
If you receive merchandise that you didn’t order, you have a legal right to keep it as a free gift… You have no legal obligation to notify the seller.
I'll still keep it lol.
You shouldn't have to. It's admirable that you're trying to help them out though and fix the error.
Thanks, guys. I was debating about keeping it initially, but I thought about someone missing out on it plus they emailed me directly. I definitely don't feel bad about my response now. We'll see if it's still there today. I wish I responded earlier, didn't know I could legally keep it.