Well, I'm assuming you like both characters somewhat equally. If you are a much bigger Dark Phoenix fan and are only considering GR because he looks awesome, then I strongly suggest you buy Dark Phoenix. Buying statues based purely on how they look is a mistake IMO. If you don't have a strong tie to the character, that's usually the first piece you'll end up selling if you need money or space. Also, it's more likely you'll get bored of a piece if you have little intrest in the character. I like GR but he's far down the list of characters that are my most favorite. I'm mainly an X-MEN and Avengers fan. So, I save whatever money and room I have to focus on those characters. Ultimately, that's why I passed on the XM Ghost Rider but still POd the XM transformation HULK. Even through the XM transformation HULK is a very expensive statue, I'm floored by the sculpt and love the character so it is a MUST HAVE for me personally. That's my 2 cents on the topic. Hope it helps and good luck with whatever statue you buy. Both look great.