There is the Zavvi rereleases of the 9-12 that are much cheaper than these new ones.
I like the new 12 better. I already have the first 10, original 11 and 7b 11, and while I like 9 enough, I'm in no hurry to get him. 8, War & 9 are "maybes" when I'm done collecting everything else I really want. So it comes down to 12, and I prefer the latter look to his earlier one, so it's this version that I want.
That cartoony comment is just how I described them to a mate.
Capaldi is the best of the bunch with David looking the most cartoony, but his outfit looks awesome.
Is it worth spending £1000 to upgrade? I don’t know.
I like all my original figures just fine.
If I had none of the originals, I would be jumping on this set.
I'd say a resounding "no". BCS already charged too much, if people buy this en masse we'll be seeing them get the Taboo license and asking 400 quid for a Tom Hardy in a top hat. If someone's a DW uber-fan and absolutely needs these, a one-off buy even though they don't buy many 1/6th stuff, I kinda get it. But as upgrades? Of the whole set? Come on, that's just plain silly. They already look weird and cartoony with non-mass-produced paint applications and they don't even have any signatures. Yeah, the suits are much more form fitting this time around, but is that really worth 300 quid? My 10 is a bit frumpy, but he's got his signature and I'm fine with it. 7b 11 has better tailoring and that's my favourite look of his anyhow. I'll be biting the bullet for a 12, as I don't have him and I need him, but in no way do I think they are actually worth the money.
It comes down to how much a diehard Whofan one is, and if there's literally anything else they'd rather get. But unless I had millions in the bank and nothing to spend them on, no other figures I wanted, no new car, whatever, only then I'd give 1K pounds for upgraded dollies. Hot Toys is already charging 500$ for a Carnage. By the time the F4 & X-Men roll around we'll be paying 300$ for a basic figure, 500$ for the Iron Men, and 600$ for a Thanos type, while BCS will be charging 400 pounds for guys in suits.