With Disney Star Wars floundering lately, maybe Aphra could be their Deadpool equivalent of shaking up the status quo and be an edgier side of Star Wars? While Star Wars is undeniably aimed at kids (of all ages), that doesn’t mean everything needs to be. Andor certainly wasn’t for kids. Heck, Aphra and her droids are Disney creations so they should own up to them and embrace them for what they are. They can be kept in check if they hang out with Mando for an episode or two but if they had their own series or movie then maybe lean into an MA or R rating. A hard PG-13 could probably work though.
I agree with this take.
What makes it into PG-13 these days is very different from 20 years ago. I think we could easily get the murderbots into that framework.
And even then, to be colorfully dark doesn't mean it needs an R rating. I don't know if Star Wars needs that anyways.
There's a couple of things about Aphra I find interesting from a business standpoint for Disney.
-Her story is different than what we've got before, interesting, and can be sold in a pretty engaging manner.
-You can easily serialize her stories as adventures in the Star Wars universe with the occasional push to progress and overarching narrative. In other words, there's room for show writers to work, but also ways to pad out a series
-She'd be a female, minority lead that I feel would be less open to scrutiny (because there's always going to be THAT vocal audience who can't accept either of those things)
-Vader, especially because Hayden is on board again
-Merch. Can you imagine how many Glub Shittos Disney can develop for all the locations you have Aphra go to? Bars, cantinas, underworlds, ancient planets. I can see this being very lucrative in that regard.
But honestly, I think the coolest catch is simply the idea of a space Indy who works with Vader while exploring the criminal underworld feels like a pretty solid hook.
I like the Deadpool analogy to be honest. You can easily modify how intense her presence is based on where she's being used narratively as well. She's flexible in that regard and thus a good tool for Disney.
Again, the more I think about it the more it just makes too much sense to do it.