I'm convinced Tyler was a fan of the franchise. I agree, the score was spot on. Rambo is a tough watch but it's also very well made. It didn't rely solely on violence to sell the film. Though there's tons of that too
Tyler definitely get Stallone and the action genre, I kind of wish we could see him take on Rocky just to see what he'd do. His work on Rambo had me really excited and hoping he'd score Expendables and I'm glad he is because his work on those movies is great too.
As far as how tough Rambo is to watch and the violence, I was nervous in the early production when Sly made comments about trying to compete with audience demand for gore like the Saw movies, I feared he'd do gore just for the sake of gore, but most of the on screen violence was to server a purpose while carrying entertainment. The only over the top gore moment I'd say is his ripping the throat of the one soldier, a bit much. I do also think some of the deleted scenes should have been left in as they really explain and show where Rambo is at internally and make some of the moments that stayed make more sense or more powerful. The director's cut is a nice alternate take, but my ideal version is the theatrical with the deleted scenes just back in.
I do love Sly's commentaries though, he's very good at offering scene specific insight and really adding to the viewing experience unlike some directors who just use it as a couple hours to talk about whatever comes to their mind.
No doubt, he had more mass in 4 than he ever had. Though I prefer the more lean "shredded" look he had through out Rocky 3 & 4 and Rambo 2 & 3.
I just love how powerful he looks standing atop the hill after he's killed the leader of the Burmese army, between his bulk and the machete, it's just a great image, that's why I love the Rambo 4 theatrical poster so much too, they did a great job with that graphic.
First Blood is the realness. It's been said already but Rambo and Trautman in the police station at the end? That scene is amazing. I also love RAMBO.
Trautman is the only thing lacking in Rambo 4, a new performance that is, that I feel it lacks. Richard Crenna's a great actor and his job as Trautman was vital to the series I feel. I'm glad they at least worked his more important pieces of dialogue into the montage dream.