I actually ordered these the first day I found out about them. I don't think Gort is perfect (at least not to my eye) but he is clearly recognizable and with Klaatue I think the two balance out to a very nice display.
And in terms of price, Klaatu alone at $50 is a fair price, not stellar... but for a small production figure and something as iconic I don't think you'd see much better. And Gort, while not perfect is pretty much a one-off sculpt. Can't really reuse any of it so I think the price their is more than fair. And if you've seen any of the pre-existing Gort statues I think this is as good if not better and a fraction of the cost.
And I know most of the negativity was towards CF, not the figures. But just wanted to throw in my .02.