ANH Luke

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
What's a scary thought and a sigh of relief is that Ceremony Luke and Tatooine Luke should look very similar considering they are the same actor in the same movie.

Theoretically, that's true, but only in Gentle Giant land will they really look that similar. Sideshow hires hand crafting artisans to do the sculpt, and like paintings and everything else, each will interpret the character through their own artistic style. Similar as they are in style, Andy, Trev and Tim still are different looking from one another, Oluf's work is unique and so is Mat's. Had Sideshow used Mat again for this Luke, it would have been very similar to Yavin, but they went with Trev and Trev and Mat are, to me, polar opposites in style; Mat's softer in his forms and detailing, which sometimes doesn't define likeness as well, where Trev is very detailed and raw and the likeness is quite emphasized, as is seen with the Sarah Connor and Old Ben figures.
 
Yeah Trev really walks a fine line there, and thankfully he does it so well. Too much detail can really age the sculpt. Its similar to doing caricature, where you have to be careful that exaggeration can turn insulting very easily.
 
Trevor is definitely Sideshow's saving grace.

I like Trevor's sculpts as much as the rest of you do, but I am getting realy tired of the comments that Trevor is the only good sculptor at Sideshow and that he is saving them from certain doom.

Fact: Sideshow has always been the leader in the 1:6 market for likenesses.

Fact: Oluf, Matt, and many others have created beautiful sculpts which capture just as much likeness and subtlty as any Trevor has done.

Trevor is awesome, we know. But Sideshow's greatness in the sculpt department is the sum of many parts. Not just one guy.
 
I agree Pix. I think Olufs work on the likes of Sidious/Palpatine and Qui-Gon are fantastic. Matt's Lukes were good if a tad .. hm soft I guess is the best word. Andy's stuff was ALWAYS good too. If anything I think we could say that Trevor is Andy's successor in that he seems to capture the sculpt really well, if not perfectly but the style is (not that it's bad) a caricature style, which seems to work well for all parties involved. Now imagine the figures we could get if Andy was back in the fold :drool
 
I like Trevor's sculpts as much as the rest of you do, but I am getting realy tired of the comments that Trevor is the only good sculptor at Sideshow and that he is saving them from certain doom.

Too true! Sideshow wouldn't be where it is now if it weren't for all the other amazing artist.
 
What's funny about people thinking Trev is the saving grace of the line is the fact that he's had so little a part of it to date and the line has been getting better and better with each new release, Yavin Luke being the only seeming step backward. Trev's Ben is undeniably amazing, but it also has some of the best paint apps. I think Mat's ANH Luke for the Yavin figure captures Hammil, in Mat's style, and blends well with the Bespin and Jedi portraits, but the paint apps weren't the best in the line and didn't highlight his efforts as well.

Trev, in his humble way, is right in that it takes more steps from what he does to deliver the final piece that woo's us. Ben's sculpt is great, but if his paint hadn't turned out so well it may not have been the awesome figure we all think it is, but paint was right and tailoring and accessories well done also.

Trev hasn't save this line, Sideshow is growing and getting better, it's just coincidental that at the point where SSC is really rolling out their best stuff yet, Trev happens to be the sculptor tasked with the portraits of these figures. I'm sure if Palps and Sidious turn out as well as Ben, people will start singing Oluf's praises. I admit I praise Trev's awesome work, but I also do it for all the sculptors and if I knew names that went into the other parts of their figures I'd give them props, especially things like the Old Ben saber hilt, it's extremely detailed for such a small accessory and someone put a lot of quality time and work into it which paid off.

I'm glad to get portraits by Trev, but if he wasn't doing them, we'd still be getting great figures.

I favor some of the sculptors over others not because I feel they're better, but like any art, there's a style and I happen to like a certain style, like preferring a DaVinci over a Picasso, they both did people, but I prefer DaVinci's method of presenting them. I'm detailed in my artwork, so I find favor for other artist that focus on and capture the minute details in pieces.
 
Minutia is fun, especially in the saber designs. They actually have the interior of the emitter area sculpted a bit. Just think of the dexterity required to sculpt that. I guess it goes in with my major that I like fine details on things, and the folks that work on the smaller aspects of the lines (i.e. weapons and hardware) should be recoginized in some way by SS. Maybe a feature on the production blog? I think that would be a great thing to do for SS, have a staff area of the page where it lists the contributing artisans and highlights some of their work. Then we could know all the sculptors, not just the portrait artists. We could know the tailors, maybe even the proto painters. GIVE ME MORE DETAILS MAN! :lol
 
Hot Toys included "Cast" cards with their Pirates figures, it listed off all the artists involved in the figures, in a movie poster credits style.
 
There are several great and talented sculptors and artisans working on these figures, but I for one have no problem if people want to choose a favorite or someone they think is the best sculptor or whatever. It's all subjective anyway.
 
Last edited:
There are several great and talented sculptors and artisans working on these figures, but I for one have no problem is people want to choose a favorite or someone they think is the best sculptor or whatever. It's all subjective anyway.

I think there's a difference between expression of favoritism though, an implication that all else is utter failure with no value.
 
:lol :lol :lol :lol

That was great.

Signed,

Karl, Sean and Marc

:lol :lol Made me giggle. So back to Luke now..

Let's see we know he comes with the Sabers, binoculars.. something makes me think that the hat and poncho will come standard along with the rifle so it's either the blast helmet or his T-16 which will be his exclusive me thinks.
 
I think Mat's ANH Luke for the Yavin figure captures Hammil, in Mat's style, and blends well with the Bespin and Jedi portraits, but the paint apps weren't the best in the line and didn't highlight his efforts as well.

I have to disagree with this statement. Mat's ROTJ and ESB Lukes are great but his Yavin Luke was a mulligan. Even with the paint apps applied by some of the best customizers like Les, the figure still falls really short. The facial sculpt doesn't blend at all with the other two and really looks like something thrown together Hasbro style at the last minute IMHO. Trevor's Luke is amazing and I think that Luke with his detailing and his likeness captured perfectly really fits in better with Mat's other Lukes than Mat's Yavin. Trev's is better by comparison but when thinking of the line as a whole its the perfect compliment to get three great Lukes.
 
I like Trevor's sculpts as much as the rest of you do, but I am getting realy tired of the comments that Trevor is the only good sculptor at Sideshow and that he is saving them from certain doom.

You're right, he's not their only good sculptor, but he is their best imo. Trevor is to SSC what Yulli is to HT. Heck, I think he's even more important because SSC doesn't have high quality tailoring or a great base body to offset any deficiencies in the sculpts. So when you live and die by the sculpts, a guy who hits a grand slam everytime up to the plate is a saving grace imo.
 
Let's see we know he comes with the Sabers, binoculars.. something makes me think that the hat and poncho will come standard along with the rifle so it's either the blast helmet or his T-16 which will be his exclusive me thinks.

I'm thinking there might be an issue with the blast helmet actually fitting on his head properly so my guess is the T-16. I'd love to get that either way though.
 
Back
Top