Better Trilogy: Raimi's Spider-Man or Nolan's Dark Knight?

[karamazov80]

Batman would still win. Nolan's films have twilight like cult following.

Agreed. Or Lord of the Rings.

Butchered story? Name one comic book movie that was close to source material besides Sin City and watchman?

Only a few vague connections to Year One. The villains were damn near unrecognizable, and the third film. . .man. . .

 

[cerealkeller]

Voted Nolan's Batman. Spider-Man had a really great first half. Once Green Goblin appears he kills the movie for me. Spider-Man 2 is just about perfect. Spider-Man 3 my girlfriend stopped me from walking out of the midnight show. Garbage.

Batman Begins is just about perfect. A few cringe worthy lines but they can't take away the brilliance of the film. TDK is also just about perfect, but it suffers from a rushed Two-Face story and he is my favorite Batman villain. TDKR is really good. Not the direction I wanted Nolan to take the story, but it is still a really good movie. I have no problem with Batman quitting (or finding peace I guess), my problem still comes from BB and TDK building up the perfect Batman and TDKR saying he then retired for 8 years. That is hard to swallow.

But Nolan's trilogy easily beats Raimi's trilogy for me.

 

[The Josh]

Agreed. Or Lord of the Rings.
.

Might as well strive for greatness

 

[crows]

Voted Nolan's Batman. Spider-Man had a really great first half. Once Green Goblin appears he kills the movie for me. Spider-Man 2 is just about perfect. Spider-Man 3 my girlfriend stopped me from walking out of the midnight show. Garbage.

Batman Begins is just about perfect. A few cringe worthy lines but they can't take away the brilliance of the film. TDK is also just about perfect, but it suffers from a rushed Two-Face story and he is my favorite Batman villain. TDKR is really good. Not the direction I wanted Nolan to take the story, but it is still a really good movie. I have no problem with Batman quitting (or finding peace I guess), my problem still comes from BB and TDK building up the perfect Batman and TDKR saying he then retired for 8 years. That is hard to swallow.

But Nolan's trilogy easily beats Raimi's trilogy for me.

agree with everything you said.

 

[CelticPredator]

Raimi's has Bruce Campbell.

Nolan's flicks has Nolan, who is an overrated hack. **** Nolan. He's the anti christ!

.

 

[intothevoid]

Lol not even a contest

 

[ironwez20]

I must say that Spider-Man was the better hero and didnt quit like a baby and run away after getting his ass kicked by a midget. Spider-Man is not alot better tho he was such a damn crybaby and dumbass but still he made was alot better than some "dur I gotta inspire the city so Dey can fight themselves cuz I hate being batman. Spider-Man knew he had a responsibility.

 

[thenammagazine]

Lol not even a contest

Campbell all the way!

 

[crows]

I must say that Spider-Man was the better hero and didnt quit like a baby and run away after getting his ass kicked by a midget. Spider-Man is not alot better tho he was such a damn crybaby and dumbass but still he made was alot better than some "dur I gotta inspire the city so Dey can fight themselves cuz I hate being batman. Spider-Man knew he had a responsibility.

Batman did quit because of a midget, I guess there's that. I guess at least it took Spiderman to loose his F___ng powers to quit, while all it took for Batman to quit is killing his girlfriend.

 

[jye4ever]

BB/TDK/TDKR > S1/S2/S3

Sorry, it just is.

 

[CelticPredator]

Campbell >>>>>> Whiney Pfister.

 

[ironwez20]

IMO sm2 is miles better than bb.

 

[jye4ever]

IMO sm2 is miles better than bb.

I love S1/S2

but nope

 

[ironwez20]

Batman did quit because of a midget, I guess there's that. I guess at least it took Spiderman to loose his F___ng powers to quit, while all it took for Batman to quit is killing his girlfriend.

Which is sad. Batman was completely broken by the death of Jason Todd who was the second robin. It took him years to accept another robin again. He was depressed and disheartend for the longest time but he didn't ***** out and run away with catwoman. He worked at batman even harder making him more lethal.

 

[ironwez20]

I love S1/S2

but nope

Whatever you say. Many people may disagree but I thought tdk was the best of the trilogy.

 

[jye4ever]

Which is sad. Batman was completely broken by the death of Jason Todd who was the second robin. It took him years to accept another robin again. He was depressed and disheartend for the longest time but he didn't ***** out and run away with catwoman. He worked at batman even harder making him more lethal.

Go ahead and hit the lotto, even a fraction of what BW is worth and lets see how fast you quit your profession.

 

[DiFabio]

They both suck.

I'm sick of hearing about them in every thread. Spider-Man this, Batman that, Nolan, Nolan, Nolan. They can all suck it.

You're all worthless nerds stuck on a single obsession.

Close thread.

Eat ****.

You spend too much on toys.

Never happy.

Argue too much.

 

[Maglor]

Wait... people have actually voted for Spiderman???

 

[jye4ever]

They both suck.

I'm sick of hearing about them in every thread. Spider-Man this, Batman that, Nolan, Nolan, Nolan. They can all suck it.

You're all worthless nerds stuck on a single obsession.

Close thread.

Eat ****.

You spend too much on toys.

Never happy.

Argue too much.

Wait... people have actually voted for Spiderman???

 

[intothevoid]

Wait... people have actually voted for Spiderman???

Go figure

It's the equivalent of comparing LOTR to harry potter