Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier (SPOILERS)
- Thread starter Khev
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
Re: Captain America 2
Joss's TV shows were not indie comedy fare like Arrested Development and Happy Endings. They had action, comedy, and character interactions that geek comic fans could (and did) get behind. And I'm not sure how dealing with Shakesperean stuff can't prepare you for any kind of dramatic undertaking, considering that Shakespeare's work was brilliant and the stories and interactions of the characters are as complex and relevant as anything else ever made. But specifically, Henry the V was right up Thor's alley all the way. I'm not familiar with these romantic comedies Branagh is so well known for that you are referring to. He maybe starred in some.
tomandshell
Blue Flame of the West/Mod
Re: Captain America 2
My Lord
Super Freak
Re: Captain America 2
This doesn't bode well. Generally speaking, any film that is co-directed by "brothers" ends up a steaming pile of poo more often times than not.
This doesn't bode well. Generally speaking, any film that is co-directed by "brothers" ends up a steaming pile of poo more often times than not.
tomandshell
Blue Flame of the West/Mod
Re: Captain America 2
Branagh had done heroic Shakespeare stuff, Whedon wrote comic books and TV shows with large ensemble casts, Shane Black has written classic action movies and worked with RDJ, and Favreau had some experience with visual effects. I'm not saying that two guys who made a romantic comedy shouldn't be considered, but it wasn't even a good romantic comedy.
Captain America 2 is losing the patriotic WWII time period, all the period supporting cast, the interaction with Iron Man/Thor/Hulk, and a director who nailed the tone of the original. It's going to be a challenge for anyone, and their choice of director(s) is really strange to me. Maybe they just want someone who will work for cheap and do exactly what the producers tell them.
Branagh had done heroic Shakespeare stuff, Whedon wrote comic books and TV shows with large ensemble casts, Shane Black has written classic action movies and worked with RDJ, and Favreau had some experience with visual effects. I'm not saying that two guys who made a romantic comedy shouldn't be considered, but it wasn't even a good romantic comedy.
Captain America 2 is losing the patriotic WWII time period, all the period supporting cast, the interaction with Iron Man/Thor/Hulk, and a director who nailed the tone of the original. It's going to be a challenge for anyone, and their choice of director(s) is really strange to me. Maybe they just want someone who will work for cheap and do exactly what the producers tell them.
thenammagazine
Super Freak
Re: Captain America 2
I say good riddance to WWII. There's only so far they can take that and after closing that chapter at the end of TFA and having him in Avengers, it would seem really odd to suddenly do a prequel. I'm curious to see how they're going to handle America's Super Soldier while our country's still at war.
I say good riddance to WWII. There's only so far they can take that and after closing that chapter at the end of TFA and having him in Avengers, it would seem really odd to suddenly do a prequel. I'm curious to see how they're going to handle America's Super Soldier while our country's still at war.
Re: Captain America 2
Yeah, it's and odd choice and it could backfire we shall see. I don't think Marvel is gonna let that happen. You don't shoot the goose that laid the golden egg and this run of movies has been it.
Yeah, it's and odd choice and it could backfire we shall see. I don't think Marvel is gonna let that happen. You don't shoot the goose that laid the golden egg and this run of movies has been it.
thenammagazine
Super Freak
Re: Captain America 2
I think Iron Man is said goose.
I think Iron Man is said goose.
Re: Captain America 2
Our country was at war the first time he was unfrozen. I assume they'll handle it the same way they did then.
Our country was at war the first time he was unfrozen. I assume they'll handle it the same way they did then.
Re: Captain America 2
Well, it's the choicest part of the goose for sure.
I think Iron Man is said goose.
Well, it's the choicest part of the goose for sure.
thenammagazine
Super Freak
Re: Captain America 2
While that's true, it's a completely different type of war. I'd love to see how Cap would deal with it.
While that's true, it's a completely different type of war. I'd love to see how Cap would deal with it.
Spartan Rex
Super Freak
- Joined
- May 26, 2006
- Messages
- 8,130
- Reaction score
- 381
Re: Captain America 2
Not digging this choice at all.
Just when you start think you understand Marvels director selection mindset you get this.
Yoikes.
Not digging this choice at all.
Just when you start think you understand Marvels director selection mindset you get this.
Yoikes.
tomandshell
Blue Flame of the West/Mod
Re: Captain America 2
Everybody can root for Captain America when he is involved in a war against the Nazis, but even then they downplayed the Nazis and focused on Hydra. Putting Cap in the middle of a polarizing and controversial contemporary war is going to divide the audience. I assume he will be going on a mission against a terrorist super villain rather than being shown as an American soldier on the front lines in Afghanistan, etc.
Everybody can root for Captain America when he is involved in a war against the Nazis, but even then they downplayed the Nazis and focused on Hydra. Putting Cap in the middle of a polarizing and controversial contemporary war is going to divide the audience. I assume he will be going on a mission against a terrorist super villain rather than being shown as an American soldier on the front lines in Afghanistan, etc.
thenammagazine
Super Freak
Re: Captain America 2
Given his outfit pretty much exploits the American flag, I don't think they'll be too worried about how the film would do in those areas though.
Given his outfit pretty much exploits the American flag, I don't think they'll be too worried about how the film would do in those areas though.
Re: Captain America 2
They should have just let Tommy Lee Jones direct it.
They should have just let Tommy Lee Jones direct it.
Shropt
Super Freak
Re: Captain America 2
I really don't see why they are even making another Cap film. His first movie told all of the story that anyone wanted to see. What could they possibly do in a sequel (with no supporting superheroes) that would actually be interesting or worth doing?
I really don't see why they are even making another Cap film. His first movie told all of the story that anyone wanted to see. What could they possibly do in a sequel (with no supporting superheroes) that would actually be interesting or worth doing?
Similar threads
