After reading through the rest of the thread, I’d say this wins best post:
Sigh.
So this bit from the article Buffinator linked
Sure it's a good thing - assuming these people want the job and are qualified. If they don't want the job and they aren't qualified then they shouldn't just arbitrarily be granted jobs for arbitrary reasons but I assume that's not the case.
But, y'know, a handy way of avoiding the whiny backlash might just be to do all this inclusion stuff minus the public references to too many white men. It should be possible to do what you want to do without making it seem like white men as a group are a 'problem'. When you have 2 options and you know one of those options will cause the backlash - and that's the one you choose - you must bear some blame.
Ask yourselves, might we actually be doing something needlessly wrong here? Make the necessary adjustment and then see how it goes. Just try it on for size. And if white men still take issue with it, as I said yesterday, then you've probably identified the genuine arseholes. But you did it by a more careful process that didn't simply expect all good white men not to be offended when you intimate that white men are a problem. You can't say 'too many black people', you can't say 'too many women', you can't say 'too many jewish people' or 'too many *insert any other grouping*'
Be consistent within your own principles.
This is on point. There’s no problem with people wanting more inclusiveness or more diversity. It’s about HOW you go about doing it. You don’t need to demonize/tear one group down to build another up.
In Brie’s comments, both current and past, she always makes a big statement about how she doesn’t want to hear white men’s opinions or she doesn’t want them around, and then goes on to say what her main point was, though it seems secondary by then. Of course the headlines reflect this (quite proudly)
Now imagine, if all she said was, ‘In this press tour I want to give a voice to those whose voices haven’t been heard, and I want to reach out to minorities who have been unfairly represented thus far’ (or some such)
It’s like a-dev said, whoever disagreed with that statement would be a complete a-hole, and everyone would instantly know it.
The thing is, these people don’t actually want equality. They use it as an excuse to attack a group of people they dislike, because what they really want is revenge, masquerading as virtue.
All you have to do is compare Brie (or any other current person using the same ideology) to examples of people who truly want equality.
Take MLK as an example:
I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood.
I have a dream that one day even the state of Mississippi, a state sweltering with the heat of injustice, sweltering with the heat of oppression, will be transformed into an oasis of freedom and justice.
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.
I have a dream today!
I have a dream that one day, down in Alabama, with its vicious racists, with its governor having his lips dripping with the words of "interposition" and "nullification" -- one day right there in Alabama little black boys and black girls will be able to join hands with little white boys and white girls as sisters and brothers
He does specifically call out the racists but doesn’t insult the entire race while he’s at it, and specifically points out that it’s content of character vs skin color that matters. That’s pure class, all the way.
Let me also add I say all this being non white. In fact my parents are an interracial couple (neither white) who faced a lot of racism back in the day as they ‘weren’t’ allowed to marry back then. But they hold no grievances in their hearts for those who made trouble for them, as they know that’s just a way to keep the hate alive.
Well while i am Australian my background is Greek so really i am not the "white" person she is talking about. But it doesn't matter if she said white, black, asian, indian if she targets any audience for an agenda i have an issue with it even if its not me.
Exactly. Racism is racism. I can’t believe some people think it’s allowable under certain circumstances.
Racism is always wrong.
That's how pathologically stupid these ideologues are who shill based on identity politics. The very act of them shilling directly contributes to a film's underperformance. They learned absolutely nothing from the failure of Ghostbusters 2016 or the success of WW. Nothing at all.
Yup. If you make enemies of your audience, tell them how superior you are and act like they need to learn something from you while you insult them at the same time, why will they show up? Although this is marvel and endgame is coming up, so it might not exactly end up being ghostbusters 2016
And your previous point of GG and BL being polar opposites is bang on. GG is the girl I’d want to marry, BL is the one I’d want to divorce (based purely on personality, not getting into looks. Subjective opinion of course)