Well, yes, that's about you - but a huge chunk of the comics collectors in the community probably have Magneto in their top 5, easily. Magneto's pieces always seem to appreciate a lot, look at Koto's Magneto, Bowen action Magneto, MadX custom... only the SS comiquette didn't make it, lol.
I agree with the sentiment about the first PF. If I want a Doom piece, I want a
Doom piece... not an awesome throne with an average Doom on it.
But comparing the two, you're basically comparing a Doom with no details on his armor (original PF) to one that has a couple of sculpted ornaments, not highlighted by an average/subpar paint app. The latter wins, yes, but overall is still pretty average for the price point.
Making another comparison with another armored piece - the details on Doom's armor are a joke compared to the Reaper LSF, in any way you consider the thing. Sculpt, paint app, intricacy. The Reaper literally blows this one out of the water - for half the price.
It's an odd situation... compared to other LSFs (except Reaper and maybe Wolf), this one is definitely better. Switch outs, pedestal for the unused mask, a decent non-random-circular base, even an unmasked portrait... but if I think about it long enough I can't help but say that it's a lot of robe on a decent sculpt and average paint app. Definitely overpriced.
But not trying to put down those who bought it, if they like it, go for it.
I'll keep waiting for someone to produce the definitive Doom, 1:4 or 1:3 scale