It might just take time. There was a lot of backlash against TNG at first, they didn't really hit their stride until S3. And I hated DS9 when it first came on - it just didn't feel like Star Trek. Of course, I was 8. Now, it's a fan favorite, and for good reason. But it didn't hit it's stride until S3 either. Enterprise was ok, but overall weak until S4 - too bad it never got a chance to grow into it's own.
For me, TOS and VOY are the outliers on that one - TOS S1 were some of it's strongest stories, and VOY IMHO went downhill the longer the show went on when it became a TNG clone with the Borg as the only baddies.
But nonetheless, I'm judging something that's incomplete, and I will be happy to be proven wrong down the line, it's just not grabbing me thus far. That said, each season has been a bit stronger than the one that came before, so who knows?
DSC was also an experiment, and had so many behind-the-scenes issues - three different creative directions by the time S2 came out. OOF. No wonder it didn't know what it was. Still not sure it does.