Green Lantern---Blackest Night (Spoilers)

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Read today's books. GL was great. Sinestro finally defeated Mongul and regained complete control of his Corp. He didn't kill him (yet) so he wouldn't join the black lanterns. Now he Hal, Indigo-1, and Carrol are teaming up. So that is 4 of the 7 already working together. Just need blue, red, and orange (if Agent Orange comes out alive!). Oh, and Abin Sur and his sister show up at the end!

Titans 2 was a lot like Superman 2. Mostly a filler issue with little plot moving forward. Donna gets bitten by her baby black lantern and it seems it is infecting her. Hawk 2 joins Hawk 1 in fighting Dove 2. Dove still isn't showing an emotion though. Just white glowing. So that is still hinting at a white lantern Dove 1 if you ask me. And the Titan's Tower is buried. The rest was just more fighting with no plot really moving forward. Hopefully 3 of both this and Superman will be better. So far Batman is the only one that is 2 for 2 on being really good.
 
Got today's books--look really cool--Buttmunch --I did not read your post--I will come back and read
TT--sold out at my LCS
 
BN Titans #2 and BN GL both were great reads. The plot thickens (again) with what happens on Korugar. And Donna Troy is screwed.
 
Re: DC's Blackest Night: a Blatant rip-off of a Alan Moore story !!!!!

I increasingly get a sense of the comics industry going through my trashcan like raccoons in the dead of the night… That’s a good image, isn’t it? They weren’t even particularly good ideas.
We are seeing the death of comics publishing as we know it.
Pick up those ideas and do something new with them. Make them shine again. But, I think that it’s been a long time since the comics industry had any talent that was capable of doing that.
I tend to see the people who run the comics industry as being largely like some variety of tapeworm or some other parasite. But, they’re not very good at it. Any self-respecting tapeworm or parasite never kills the host.
I very seriously doubt whether the comics industry as we know it is going to be here in even five years’ time.
I think the lights are going out all over the comics industry. A lot of this is the fault of the publishers, a lot of it is the fault of the artists and writers, and I think, as you say, some of it is the fault of the readers.
there was something poignant about that that was almost saying perhaps superheroes would have been best left in those three decades—the ‘40s to the ‘60s—where they made sense and where they were most at home.

I wish he would just say how he really fells :lol
 
Re: DC's Blackest Night: a Blatant rip-off of a Alan Moore story !!!!!

So a crazy man claims an 8 pg. story of his was copied, provides no insight of how or show proof and somehow an entire series is a rip-off? If this thread isn't fail, fail doesn't exist.
 
:lol

Actually Ethan Van Sciver lashed out at Alan Moore about this already.

"Ridiculous. At no point during the conversation Geoff and I had in creating Blackest Night did any of us bring up anything Alan Moore ever did. It'd be difficult. I've never read any of it.

I think the idea came first, and Geoff kind of retrofitted it into some classic Green Lantern continuity using some pieces and parts of old stories. It's what he does. He has ideas, and he graciously fits them in to the whole DCU timestream so as to compliment what came before him. It's everyone's job to continue the Big Story.

But the idea that we sat around pining to create something, ANYTHING, and had to resort to repeating something Alan Moore did 25 years ago...well, that's delusional."

Johns confirmed that he did in fact try really hard to tie the storyline back to established DC Canon instead of Retconning everything as he has been accused of many times over. He has been tying things to the Booster Gold series (which details a lot of the "future" of New Earth) and has even been looking at his beloved Legion to tie events together, which is part of the charm of the series because it feels like it should happen instead of something that was forced to happen and change things like many events have a tendancy to be.

So Alan Moore is right they are using bits of his original idea but what he is forgetting is that Johns looked for something in GL history to tie Blackest Night to and his original prophecy fit the bill but if Alan Moore did a little more research there are major parts of his original story that are left out of Blackest Night purposely because they would be too hard to introduce.
 
Man, Alan Moore is a great writer but is such a jackass it's astounding. Maybe someone should go through a list of his works and nitpick the 'original' ideas he's had in the past-- League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comes to mind insomuch as ALL of the main characters are torn out of Victorian-era novels (Not to mention the fact that LOEG is, fundamentally, a Victorian-era 'multi-company crossover' that I'm sure Alan loathes so much).
I think "Blackest Night" was born out of serendipedous coincidence (certainly true if Ethan Van Sciver's reply to this nonsense is to be believed) and Mr. Johns was simply paying homage to what came before when stumbling upon the stories that Mr. Moore refers to.
I love Moore's work, but to say that borrowing from throwaway ideas that he came up with (that he didn't even consider 'good' ideas) just seems like bitterness on his part. Every time he goes to weigh in on issues regarding the state of current comics I just wish for the ability to tell him to shut up in person.
I haven't even had a chance to read any of BN yet and look forward to doing so when they're collected. But from what I have read of Geoff Johns' work, he's definitely one of the good guys in comics right now. Yes, the industry is a mess right now. Yes, there are many, MANY stupid ideas out there (some being the fault of stupid ideas that came before), but Johns seems to be able to make sense of it all, to make even the silly ideas matter and mean something (even if he's resurrecting Barry Allen for what? The second or third time?) and I enjoy them.
Are they running out of original ideas? Sure. Everyone is. I'd go so far as to say that there are no original ideas, just original takes on tried-and-true formulas, and comics are one of the few media left where you don't have to worry about there being budget constraints and censor notes and editorial changes being made NEARLY as much as television or movies.

If Alan Moore is so offended by this then he should write something 'original' and let his work speak for him. And by the way, the last time he let his work be a commentary on the comics industry, it was The Killing Joke, where he was conveying that the status quo never changes, i.e. Batman would never kill the Joker and vice versa. Ironically, that was the story where Batgirl was crippled, which remains a permanent change... I don't hear him giving the Batman writing and editorial staff any flak for that.
 
LOL... pathetic at best. Seems like Alan Moore is just upset about missing the boat on ideas that he thought weren't good enough. I'd also like to tell him to shut up as he just seems to come as a whiny girl in that article.
 
Moore has been petty and insane for quite awhile now.

I'll take Johns over Moore any day.

Moore's ludicrus & delusional rant = EPIC FAIL

QFT! Ive never read anything this mook has ever written because I find it contrived and quite frankly boring. He needs to crawl back into that beard of his and go away permanently.
 
Just read Titans 2 and 46. Titans 2 was the same idea as Superman 2 where it was or at least felt unfinished, unneeded. As if you could have cut them in half and put them to part 1 and part 3 and make a two part series. GL 46 was good, I liked the BLs dismantling Zamaron homeworld but the Sinestro/Mongul fight was a lot of hype that didn't pan out. I didn't like the ring loophole being the reason for the win but I was interested seeing Abin Sur again. Still loving the series but these weren't as Earth shattering as the ones before.
 
Im such a geek-when I was reading GL 46, at the conclusion of the Sinestro Mongul fight, I let out a quick "oh no!" outloud that Mongul was going to become a BL. My wife looked at me like a weirdo haha! I love it though, as I have not collected comics since '93-'94!

On another note, is it worth while to pick up some of the variant covers? Just as a little collectable? I really like a few of them but I am hesitant as they go from $15-$25 depending on the title.
 
No BL this week sucks. Although I did just download the entirety of GL v3 to catch up on so I can read that I guess.
 
Back
Top