I would like some advice on buying my first handgun. I am going handgun shopping this weekend and I am leaning towards buying a Springfield XMD compact. I will mostly only "carry" it when we go camping and hiking, so I want something light and compact, but still want to have a decent size capacity for home defense etc. The one thing I am worried about with the XDM is the lack of a safety. Is that a big deal? I also see a lot of people liking 1911s. Why are they so popular and is it something I should consider over the XDM? Any and all feedback will be appreciated.
First things first...I suggest that you get at least some basic training in handgun usage. Some states require it, but even if you live in a state that does not, it is always a good idea.
The 1911s are very popular because they are a great design that has withstood the test of time and done so with flying colors. There is very little that can be argued against them.
Your own choice for a weapon is going to be a very personal choice. Your needs and limitations for things like home defense such as how close your neighbors are and the likely types of threats (armed vs unarmed, single intruders vs groups...etc), and camping/hunting will dictate things like caliber, propellant requirements and magazine capacity.
I do not own a XDm. But I have heard nothing terrible about it. Most of the complaints I have heard can be attributed to personal preferences of the people making the complaints. I am almost loath to say it as I don't want it to affect your decision, but the XDs almost seem a little
too safe, for me. It is not that it does not have a safety, it just doesn't have a thumb safety.
It is important that you taylor the gun to your needs and what you are comfortable with. And yes, safety should be a cornerstone consideration, so make absolutely certain that you are as comfortable with the safety of the weapon as you are with the fit of it in your hand.
Edit - Oh, yeah...and good luck with your first purchase. I hope you are happy with your choice!