Watched this last night.
Never read the Hellboy comics. Only watched the live action movies.
First movie looked fantastic. Hellboys birth, Kronen, Abe. The actors seemed to fit their parts. But the overall story was meh and the constant fighting of the demon dogs got old quick.
Second movie, it was ok. Pretty much more of the same. It's major failure was being release a week before The Dark Knight.
The third one, I don't remember much from. I recall it being more violent than the other 2 and Hellboy had an ugly face and it flopped.
Hellboy: The Crooked Man. Yea, it looks like a fan film. No big deal. Just tell your story. Thought Hellboy looked the best in this. Crooked Man was kinda neat. The rest was . . . . boring. Good call not to put this into theaters because it drags. Prolly won't hear about another live adaption for a while.