Hey guys,
I am really tempted by this Cap, I think he looks really good. I have the Civil War version which I think is pretty good but I like a few things like the scalemail on this better. How do you guys think the Endgame version compares to the Civil War version? Thanks in advance
The Civil War version is indeed a favorite among Cap collectors because of the color scheme and body build but I gotta say the Endgame is the better figure.
BUILD
While not perfect, the Endgame figure has better proportions and addresses the thing everyone seems to gravitate towards - trapezius muscles. Some would?ve liked to see them more pronounced but seriously you can only tell in museum poses. The traps are more visible in the Endgame version. Also, in a couple reviews and blog pics, it seems to finally be able to pull off the pose where Cap grabs his shield off his back. With Civil War?s fabric, I always have a fear of ripping the fabric and/or splitting a seam. All in all, The build and proportions seem to be only second to the much slimmer Concept Art version. Considering the amount of bulk, armor and scales, I?d say it?s a good compromise. One thing I think they should?ve considered was maybe slightly increasing the size of the helmeted headsculpt so it could match more closely to the rest of the body.
COSTUME
A lot of people, myself included, initially did or do not like the ?plasticky/cheap? looking costume used on the Infinity War/Endgame but I finally warmed up to it seeing all of my Caps side by side. The IW/Endgame just ?sticks? to the body better much like spandex. We were all accustomed to the look/feel of fabric but there were always air pockets particularly in the abdominal area that looked weird in poses. Not to mention, Chris Evans wasn?t running around in cloth in the movies. The synthetic look is much more utilitarian towards posing and maintaining quality over the years while I can see cloth fraying, ripping or even fading over time. Also, I hate when the cloth collar gets flimsy and bends over time. Speaking of which, the height and stiffness of the EG collar makes the costume look even more heroic now. The one thing that most will point out is the smaller star. I can take it or leave it but I just happen to have a spare Star that shouldn?t be hard to replace should I feel brave enough to try out later on down the line.
EXTRAS
Without a doubt, the Endgame has some definitive accessories especially as it reminds you of the iconic moments from the movie. I would?ve loved for Mjolnir to light up or have lightning parts but it probably still won?t deter you from recreating the many moments you can with this accessory. In addition to a whole, slightly dirty shield, The broken shield is also a must-use. You;d think a broken item would make Cap look ?weaker? but just as I display with my Iron Studios statue, it makes him look more bad-*** that he would fight to the end with whatever. A lot of people scratch their heads on the ?derpy? looking gritted teeth mouth replacement but I think it?s the face he makes when he tightens the strap on his broken shield or the face he makes when he pauses between saying ?Avengers...Assemble.? The other two faceplates are straightforward and are included with the Civil War version. In fact, they modified the EG versions to where the face particularly the nose doesn?t look as long. Now for probably the best reason to choose this figure - the new headsculpt. While not being perfect, Hot Toys added nuances in sculpt and paint app to get closer to Chris Evans likeness, namely the paler skin tone and lighter hair. It looks great...or great enough. I like that it?s not an overhaul between figures like Tony Stark headsculpts when you stand them side by side. Lastly, The Peggy timepiece is just icing on the cake and is Something I?ve always wanted as a fan of Peggy Carter, ?I?m glad they finally fit it in (and corrected the size). It might seem like a throwaway accessory to some but it really is a nice touch and much more thoughtful than the Civil War figure?s inclusion of Crossbone?s mask. The base is the standard hexagonal base to keep uniformity but honestly of all my Cap figures, this one will most likely always be posed up off of that base.
SUMMARY
So it?s pretty apparent that I choose the EG version over Civil War for sentimental reasons as well as the look of it but honestly it just seems like it would be more fun to pose. I?m sure they?ll make a Battle Damaged version just because. Other than the obvious dry brush application to the costume, I?m not sure what they could add other than a bloodied faceplate and maybe an earpiece. I wouldn?t hold my breath for it, though. This figure is executed so well that it?s a reminder of why I collect these expensive figures and why I am a Concept Artist in the industry.
I hope this helped you consider your choice. If anything, owning both will help you appreciate the evolution of artistry/engineering that goes into it.