HeubertMichael
Super Freak
I have to disagree slightly here. I wouldn't say Pfeiffer's version isn't Catwoman and doesn't pay homage to certain aspects of the character... it just doesn't portray the burglar portion. Other aspects from the character's history are there: Physical trauma as a means to creating the Catwoman persona (portrayed in the 50's origin of the character), abusive men as a catalyst (portrayed in both the Earth 2 and somewhat Miller Year One versions), and of course the romantic tension between her and Batman (which is really the core of the character's importance to the mythos).
In my eyes, the thief aspect of the character is a relatively small part of what makes Catwoman "Catwoman", and Pfeiffer's version is still plenty "Catwoman" without it.
Again, just my opinion though.
Sallah
Hmmmm. Small maybe, but equally important.
Being a thief gave her the moniker Catwoman to begin with, only given a more cat-like costume to complement Selina's activity. She's a cat-burglar, that's what she was when Batman and her first met, known only as "The Cat". The rest of things added to make her less boring, to give more life to her, and make her as complex as everyone in Gotham City/Batman mythos may be important (especially at making her different from, no pun intended, copycats such as another catburglar from the competition), but to me who she is from the very beginning, no matter how simple, defines Catwoman too, and shouldn't be omitted in any version of the character. Doing so will be like skipping on Spidey being bitten by a radioactive spider -- the simpler part of his origin as Spider-man -- while his origin as a hero began after the death of Uncle Ben.
Last edited: