GreenRanger-Kush
Super Freak
Hot Toys Batman & Batmobile - Batman Begins
I think you missed one crucial point of this Batman , especially during BvS. You have to remember, this Batman is extremely depressed and angry.
Rage can consume people to do things they could never imagine themselves doing, because they are blinded. Add depression, alcohol and pills on top of it and voila.
I agree during BvS, Batman is a terrible person, and should be in jail. But all the Batman should technically be in jail.
About the aspect of him not willing to kill anymore because his enemy (Superman) made him realise he has become the very thing he despises due to the rage. Which still doesnt make him a better person, but he is trying to do better, and in ZSJL, he even brings people together, he even opens himself up to people to assemble a team.
Sure it might not be story wise on par with TDK or Marvel, but I enjoyed it, especially the DCEU feel of his trilogy, the pacing, the visuals. Trying to do something different.
Im curious about your take on the Batman not wanting to become a executioner during BB, which is a beautiful scene and line, but then he blows up the whole building of the LoS. Doesnt that contradict with not becoming a executioner? Him indirectly killing Ras All Ghul I can live with but a whole building full of people?
The purpose of deconstructing a character is to reveal something about them, and while I guess you can say Snyder revealed something about his version of Batman, it's primarily that his version of Batman is an awful person.
One theme that travels through all three Nolan movies (the central component of of his version of the character, I would argue) is whether Bruce is doing what he does for Gotham, or for himself. It's something he struggles with in each movie. The clearest way this struggle resolves is in Bruce's decision not to become a revenge killer, or as it is written, not "become an executioner."
We see that Batman is willing to kill in battle, but his stance goes back to how he understands the problem: he once had a plot to kill a man, not in defence of himself or others, but because it would make Bruce feel better--and somebody chewed him out because that would be a selfish and bankrupt thing to do, that contributes nothing to the welfare of the city. This is the lesson Bruce carries forward, not a rule against the use of lethal force, but a belief about lethal punishment.
Snyder's Batman also has a plot to kill someone purely to make himself feel better, and... That's it, basically. He eventually decides not to do it, not because he realizes it's wrong, but because his enemy makes a plea that humanizes him in Batman's eyes, preventing Batman from seeing him as a dangerous "other." So in the end Batman only relents because killing Superman would no longer make him feel better, not because he understands his own actions and their place in any sort of moral continuum. Batman remains a terrible person, but fortunately everyone forgives him by the next movie instead of sending him to jail where he belongs.
Sure, you could say it deconstructed the character, but if we're committing to what that deconstruction reveals, well, it did not reveal a redemption story, but rather a dangerous villain who needs to be stopped.
Sent from my SM-G973W using Tapatalk
I think you missed one crucial point of this Batman , especially during BvS. You have to remember, this Batman is extremely depressed and angry.
Rage can consume people to do things they could never imagine themselves doing, because they are blinded. Add depression, alcohol and pills on top of it and voila.
I agree during BvS, Batman is a terrible person, and should be in jail. But all the Batman should technically be in jail.
About the aspect of him not willing to kill anymore because his enemy (Superman) made him realise he has become the very thing he despises due to the rage. Which still doesnt make him a better person, but he is trying to do better, and in ZSJL, he even brings people together, he even opens himself up to people to assemble a team.
Sure it might not be story wise on par with TDK or Marvel, but I enjoyed it, especially the DCEU feel of his trilogy, the pacing, the visuals. Trying to do something different.
Im curious about your take on the Batman not wanting to become a executioner during BB, which is a beautiful scene and line, but then he blows up the whole building of the LoS. Doesnt that contradict with not becoming a executioner? Him indirectly killing Ras All Ghul I can live with but a whole building full of people?