Hot Toys CMS The Dark Knight Returns 1/6th Scale Collectible Figure

[sj2106]

Criticising the execution and accuracy of the figure is fair enough but is it really worth posting just to say how much you hate Miller's art? Clearly this figure isn't for you but must accept how popular and influential The Dark Knight Returns was.

For me it's almost perfect and hopefully leads to more comic versions of Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman and other Justice League characters. The better this sells the more likely it is we get those figures.

 

[jye4ever]

Sorry but every iteration of Batman including Hush look less intimidating next to DKR.

 

[GodParticle]

Looks great to me. My favorite comic version of batman. Almost went for that 3rd party one a while ago

 

[slynger]

Miller’s art has always been divisive. However, this story came at a time when comics were tanking, big time.

One reason or another, DC okayed a grizzled, old man Bruce Wayne and let Miller run with it - arguably, the pivotal series turned the comic book world upside down.

If this sells, and I think it will, we could get a Joker, Kelly and possibly Supes.

 

[karamazov80]

Criticising the execution and accuracy of the figure is fair enough but is it really worth posting just to say how much you hate Miller's art? Clearly this figure isn't for you but must accept how popular and influential The Dark Knight Returns was.

Since the design of the figure is based off of Miller's art, I think it's a fair area of discussion. Personally I think Miller's art was at its apex in the late '70s and early '80s, where he was hinting at the expressionism that was mentioned earlier, but still keeping it conventional and aesthetically pleasing. I feel that, yes, he was getting more expressive over time, but also lazier. The simplicity of his later work must take a fraction of time to draw relative to his work on Daredevil. That was also something I observed with John Byrne. He didn't take the time to really flesh out his art starting in the late '80s, and though he is one of my all-time favorite artists, I started checking out by his run on Namor and Wolverine.

 

[Turtle882]

It's not perfect, but it is very cool. It's even cooler to see DC Comics figure getting some love. Hopefully more will follow.

I can't not chime in on Miller. He used to be a great artist and story teller. The Wolverine has great art. Ronin, 300, and DKR are great to look at. Of course, Lynn Varley's pre-digital coloring adds so much to the art. Miller's stories were great as well- Daredevil is prime long-form, while Batman Year 1 is prime short-form. Sin City is also a fun little world that has some pretty cool art. Beginning with DKSA it was all down hill. The art in that was... not great. Varley's over-the-top digital coloring didn't work. Then All Star Batman and Robin followed. Yeesh. A lot of his work post-2001 feels more like a satirical take on Frank Miller. Edgelord with bad art.

 

[bat1975]

Echoing what a lot of folks have already said: while this wouldn't have been my first choice for a comic-based Batman (mostly because there's already a number of pretty high quality 3rd party versions available), I'm just glad that the floodgates (hopefully) have opened for comic book Batman figures. Neal Adams, Jim Lee Hush, Capullo N52, Year One, etc.

 

[i_amjam]

Echoing what a lot of folks have already said: while this wouldn't have been my first choice for a comic-based Batman (mostly because there's already a number of pretty high quality 3rd party versions available), I'm just glad that the floodgates (hopefully) have opened for comic book Batman figures. Neal Adams, Jim Lee Hush, Capullo N52, Year One, etc.

Capullo N52 would be a dream. I also wouldn't mind his Rebirth design as I like the purple cape interior.

 

[Landry]

Miller’s art has always been divisive. However, this story came at a time when comics were tanking, big time.

One reason or another, DC okayed a grizzled, old man Bruce Wayne and let Miller run with it - arguably, the pivotal series turned the comic book world upside down.

If this sells, and I think it will, we could get a Joker, Kelly and possibly Supes.

Um... no? Comics were going strong in the mid 80's. This is the youth of the Direct Market, when Diamond and Capitol were spreading their distribution wings across the industry. It's pre-Image boom, sure, but that was a fairly grotesque speculator bubble that left huge scars in the industry. The early to mid-80's is otherwise legendary for growth.