Some folks still think the generic 2-in-1 Superman sculpt looks more like Routh than the first Superman release. In other words, some people apparently do not have the ability to understand that sculpt and paint work are two separate things.But the actual SS sculpt is great, the face is right, it just needed repainting.
Having said that, many don't have the inclination to get something repainted, and if you feel that way, I would go with 2-in-1 Supes or this Indy over their previously released counterparts.