That's brutal.
Thats very true but if you didn't have original and clone side by side, could one even tell? apart from the sloppy hair joins.
I can't speak for everyone, but I would (involuntarily) pick it apart and compare it with pics of the original ones and loose sleep over it.
I think you could actually, these recasts seems to loose some details and as rory puts it kinda 'soft ' sculpt.