That TaliBane always seems to make a lot of sense!
I've got to offer up my nomination to Talibane for newest poster with the highest concentration of truth bombs in his posts.
Wow, guess they IP matched him? I'd always worry if I banned an innocent guy.
Wow, why all the bashing on this huskie?
What did I miss?
So much testosterone in that shot, it would flunk a drug test.
As much as I'm a subscriber to the mostly drafted troopers idea, regardless of Morrison, the troopers in STAR WARS did in fact have only two voices. So one could surmise there are two batches of clones. I do believe that was the original intent. The fact is that the lore changed over time, and Lucas decided that the Imperial forces were draftees, volunteers and clones.
So everyone's right. Or wrong... from a certain (Lucas) point of view.
At least with the multiple batches theory (another Lucas idea) you can have your clones and height difference too.
But it's a moot point now cos the Lucasfilm Story Group has retconned them to all be "blindly patriotic" human recruits.
What you call a retcon I call an OT status quo.
Therein lies the debate!
The only debate imo is the "blindly patriotic" part. Personally, while there would have been an element of that, I would say a majority were conscripted and put through extensive "re-education". But there's no direct evidence for that in the canon.
I guess it gets back to the Nazi analogy. It's more effective if the populace buys in to the propaganda rather than getting forced. As the Lucasfilm Story Group pointed out, "blind patriotism" (their words) beats the individualism that can arise from a clone army (or reprogrammed humans). And we saw the start of the propaganda at the end of Ep III (oops, I mentioned the prequels).
Plus Luke, Biggs and co *were* keen to go to "the Academy" (though just getting off Tatooine was probably their main motivation).
But Luke, Biggs and co also made it clear they planned to jump the first ship and join the rebellion.
Enter your email address to join: