Critical Drinker called it a lot of things in his stream last night. I agree with him on a lot of things but I had to tell him I disagreed with his points on this one.
Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny (June 30th, 2023)
- Thread starter Johnny Utah
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
The estimates they spouted on my local news said $60M for the weekend. That seems dismal to me for an Indy movie opening (on the weekend before 4th of July), but I guess they are already setting expectations.
1) Raiders
2) Last Crusade
3) Dial of Destiny
4) Temple of Doom
5) Crystal Skull
Dial of Destiny surpassed my expectations and while it’s not perfect, it was a far better ending for Indiana Jones than Crystal Skull.
I’m hoping to see it again this weekend.
2) Last Crusade
3) Dial of Destiny
4) Temple of Doom
5) Crystal Skull
Dial of Destiny surpassed my expectations and while it’s not perfect, it was a far better ending for Indiana Jones than Crystal Skull.
I’m hoping to see it again this weekend.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Cop Land Sucks.
Otomofan
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2009
- Messages
- 5,229
- Reaction score
- 4,069
It was supremely disappointing. I was sooo psyched to see it. That cast was freaking insane. Had so much potential. Went out and eagerly saw it opening day....
And it was just....sucky. It was so underwhelming. Just a slightly more violent episode of "NYPD Blue" or something. Such a waste of time. I haven't had any inclination to see it since opening weekend.
They're remaking Cop Land with an all female cast. Supergirl is the lead.
*dork in the back calls out: source?*
*dork in the back calls out: source?*
Part of the issue with the box office bomb (so far) I have to believe is the lack of advertising. Im
Sure their budget is out there and I don’t know what it is but I feel personally like I just saw a trailer for this thing a month ago and then it’s just out out of nowhere and over?
I think Disney was a bit cocky here thinking an Indy movie didn’t need a lot of promotion but between that and releasing it on a holiday weekend when half of the USA at least is covered in smoke (not Disney’s fault of course) it could just be an alchemy of bad timing and bad decisions.
People seem to have a short memory and have forgotten Crystal Skull… pop that thing in and tell me this isn’t a more befitting ending and way way more on tone to the first movies.
Let’s leave the Wombat character and her baffling (to me) controversy alone for a min, and remember Marion’s smugness and her dynamic with Indy and compare it to this. All of this could have worked better in this film than it did, they made the right calls and it was handled well enough but in raiders thst dynamic ad well as the fun feeling overall… it’s just a hair more exuberant and lively and I think that’s where this film fell just slightly short here,
So My biggest issue is it’s lacking a bit of heart and is a bit boring at times but it’s a good Indy film we didn’t need it any reason not to make KOTCS the last time we saw Indy on screen.
Take away all that this is a decent film. It’s a 7/10 which is all you can hope for. It’s firm, good performances and action scenes… classic Indy charm and it’s a gorgeous looking picture overall.
People especially fanboys are gonna *****. But there is not one reboot except blade runner (and yes I’m especially counting the last ghostbuster movie) that worked. So it’s sort of in my opinion if the studios don’t leave well enough alone the best outcome is something like this film.
Thumbs up for me and I’m sticking to it!
Sure their budget is out there and I don’t know what it is but I feel personally like I just saw a trailer for this thing a month ago and then it’s just out out of nowhere and over?
I think Disney was a bit cocky here thinking an Indy movie didn’t need a lot of promotion but between that and releasing it on a holiday weekend when half of the USA at least is covered in smoke (not Disney’s fault of course) it could just be an alchemy of bad timing and bad decisions.
People seem to have a short memory and have forgotten Crystal Skull… pop that thing in and tell me this isn’t a more befitting ending and way way more on tone to the first movies.
Let’s leave the Wombat character and her baffling (to me) controversy alone for a min, and remember Marion’s smugness and her dynamic with Indy and compare it to this. All of this could have worked better in this film than it did, they made the right calls and it was handled well enough but in raiders thst dynamic ad well as the fun feeling overall… it’s just a hair more exuberant and lively and I think that’s where this film fell just slightly short here,
So My biggest issue is it’s lacking a bit of heart and is a bit boring at times but it’s a good Indy film we didn’t need it any reason not to make KOTCS the last time we saw Indy on screen.
Take away all that this is a decent film. It’s a 7/10 which is all you can hope for. It’s firm, good performances and action scenes… classic Indy charm and it’s a gorgeous looking picture overall.
People especially fanboys are gonna *****. But there is not one reboot except blade runner (and yes I’m especially counting the last ghostbuster movie) that worked. So it’s sort of in my opinion if the studios don’t leave well enough alone the best outcome is something like this film.
Thumbs up for me and I’m sticking to it!
Yeah, I was wondering how that would work. Even his movements -- when not CGI action rubberman -- would seem more elderly.
Wow! That is high praise indeed. Not that ToD doesn't have its cornball faults as I expect this one to have, but reaching all the way back to the 2nd installment... and this one could be BETTER?
I'm assuming Last Crusade is your 2nd favorite Indy movie, because there's no way you just said Dial of Destiny is the 2nd best Indy film of all time.
Yep! Correct!
It’s hard to call the new film a favorite. Nostalgia will always edge out TOD over this but ad far as the films in order of the best films IMO it goes like this.
Raiders
Last Crusade
Dial of Destiny
Temple of Doom
Crystal Skull
For me, I flip ToD and LC -- mostly because I like the villain better in ToD, despite Connery.
I'm so curious where I will find this movie on my list. I've always assumed it will slide into the #4 slot for me... as I can't find anything of value in Crystal Skull anymore, so just having Mads as the villain, and a pretend opening where we "go back" to good old Indy is enough for me to know it won't be the worst of the movies. But cracking past the old 80's adventures, I just can't see that... yet.
The Rogster
Super Freak
Raiders, TOD, Last Crusade, KOTCS, DoD.
My ranking.
Lol yup order of release unfortunately. Though I will say, the first 3 are all so close.
My ranking.
Lol yup order of release unfortunately. Though I will say, the first 3 are all so close.
Yeah, this is what I fear.
I only like a few things about TOD, mainly the opening scene, the mine cart chase and that Harrison looks the most like Indy in the early village scenes.
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2008
- Messages
- 28,384
- Reaction score
- 4,873
Did they give de-aged Ford his long neck back?
The Rogster
Super Freak
They couldn’t even take away his sagging jowls.
Does that include the part where Indy and co are in the plane up to the point where their dingy ends up by the Indian Village?
I like that whole section.
I pretty much like all of TOD apart from the really gruesome parts. The guy getting roasted alive, Indy having to drink the blood and the child whipping is a bit much, especially for a supposedly family movie.
I think all the first three Indy films have very strong openings. Raiders is by far the best though. I have heard various people say that D of D first 20 minutes in very strong then it drifts?
Last edited:
Similar threads
