Like any comic character whose been around for 20+ years, Wolverine has different interpretations.
Classicly, he's not supposed to be extremely handsome, nor particularly ugly. But he's short. So to someone like Cyclops he's little, and especially to Colossus who regularly throws him.
In Ultimate comics he was intended to be taller and more attractive
I know this is about him being ugly or not, but here's some
Marvel height comparisons, which should be the same as the official Marvel.com/characters:
5' - Mariko
5'3" - Wolverine
5'6" - Jean Grey, Kitty Pryde, X-23
5'8" - Rogue, Iceman
5'9" - Elektra, Lady Deathstrike, Nightcrawler
5'10" - Spider-Man
6' - Daredevil, Havok, Black Panther, Thing, Prof. X, Quicksilver
6'1" - Gambit
6'2" - Captain America, Deadpool
6'3" - Cyclops
6'6" - Sabretooth, Colossus (human form), Thor
7'5" - Colossus (steel)
Hunnipot85 nailed it. I think SSC's Wolverine's are fine. It's Gambit they can't get right. Gambit & Wolverine are 2 of my favorite PFs, but Gambit's cig head and the LSB just look way too old with the crow's feet around the eyes. Gambit often looks rugged in the comics, particularly during the Jim Lee days (far right pic), but he's not the 50 year old man SSC makes him look. SSC's Tony Stark looks younger by comparison.
Comics:
LSB: