It's a tough call because he looks pretty much spot on wearing the jacket, but definitely too slim at the waist without it. I think he needs a bit more padding around the hips area. At the moment his torso is a little triangular, whereas it would look improved if he was more straight down from the chest. Might be that the shirt is too 'tucked in' and would benefit from being loosened up. I know HF is in good shape but he looks paunchy in that still.
Having said all that, he still looks superb Robert.