abake
Rex Tremendae Majestatis
Sounds like a female-focused take on the book's themes of lawlessness and human nature, showing a different side of the coin -- but if it's written by men, that justification probably won't have legs. They'll be under even closer scrutiny by feminists when they were probably expecting applause.
Just a risky mix of elements here. Socio-ideological demographics don't tend to like critique or evaluation from anyone other than their own -- and even then, they rarely do it themselves. From a publicity and monetary standpoint, this should've been written by someone else or not at all.
Agree with some of the points you make.
I have no problem with the themes of Lord of the Flies being explored in an all-female environment. I actually think it's quite intriguing.
However, this has to be made be women, otherwise it kinda defeats the purpose, IMHO.