I have the Coyle's jacket from Todd's, and it's a beauty. Looks wonderful, and is not a "costume" jacket at all.
The Coyle's Indy shirt, however, is another story. It's not comfortable in the least. The cotton twill is not soft at all, but rather papery and scratchy (There's nothing like a shirt that sounds like crumpling wax paper when you move in it). I will probably never wear it again, even for my annual Halloween outing.