Oof, just checked the FB group. You weren't kidding, the eyes on those are terrible. Is that bubbling something that would've been obvious at the factory or could it have developed in the packaging over time? Sounds like a huge ES on the Goku, hopefully that means they'll have replacements for folks.
The 1/3 Predator is something I worry more and more about every week. A head can be repainted, but if the body has issues, that's far too much trouble to deal with and I'll stick with the busts.
Goes without saying that there's no reason to order P1 direct anymore. Sure, you'll get your piece sooner. Sure, you may even be able to contact them with a problem before they run out of replacements. But if you run into any obstacles at all, you're screwed. Too great a risk, I'd rather order through a retailer that has my back. Even if the statue is a dud and I have to send it back, at least they'll cover the return so I stay whole.