Eli26
Super Freak
Only 9.5 movies I can think of is the ShawShank Redemption, City of God, and now Rush. Nothing deserves a 10. As that is a perfect score and perfection simply doesn't exist.
Obviously we've got some major grade inflation in this thread, but for me, there are some legit classics that could warrant that score IMO. Not many, but films that exceed just about perfectly at what they set out to do. Citizen Kane, Casablanca, the Maltese Falcon, Dr. Strangelove, and maybe a few more modern ones like Alien, the Big Lebowski, and A History of Violence.Only 9.5 movies I can think of is the ShawShank Redemption, City of God, and now Rush. Nothing deserves a 10. As that is a perfect score and perfection simply doesn't exist.
Only God Forgives: 6.5/10
In terms of story and performances, the film was a'aight, but the objective of the film seemed to really be producing a memorable melodramatic, and at times really visceral and brutal style. The same may be said for Drive, though these films had very different ways of doing that. I'm not at all familiar with Thai films, but I wonder if the filmmaker was trying to ape the style of some of those.
Only God Forgives: 6.5/10
In terms of story and performances, the film was a'aight, but the objective of the film seemed to really be producing a memorable melodramatic, and at times really visceral and brutal style. The same may be said for Drive, though these films had very different ways of doing that. I'm not at all familiar with Thai films, but I wonder if the filmmaker was trying to ape the style of some of those.
Refn is good at getting the audience to turn away from the screen.
Obviously we've got some major grade inflation in this thread, but for me, there are some legit classics that could warrant that score IMO. Not many, but films that exceed just about perfectly at what they set out to do. Citizen Kane, Casablanca, the Maltese Falcon, Dr. Strangelove, and maybe a few more modern ones like Alien, the Big Lebowski, and A History of Violence.
I watched this again last night too. 2nd viewing.
I'd say 8/10 after reading up on the intent of the story.
its def a WTF movie the first time through.
I can't wait for 12 Years A Slave!
You should see City of God, World's Fastest Indian, and the Whale Rider. Some gems that people may not be aware of. Well, City of God everyone should know about, but you would be surprised by how few know of its existence. Frequency is also a good film, even if it's not a foreign or independent release. It's one of those Hollywood gems that slip through the cracks, like a Sandlot, Indian in the Cupboard, or Radio Flyer. Again, not everyone finds those movies their cup of tea, but I love them.
Cidade de Deus is definitely in my top 20 films of all time. It really is a remarkably powerful film.
I'll give it a shot.
I also like the Suicide Kings, Virgin Suicides (seems to be a theme here), and Green Street Hooligans.
You should see City of God, World's Fastest Indian, and the Whale Rider. Some gems that people may not be aware of. Well, City of God everyone should know about, but you would be surprised by how few know of its existence. Frequency is also a good film, even if it's not a foreign or independent release. It's one of those Hollywood gems that slip through the cracks, like a Sandlot, Indian in the Cupboard, or Radio Flyer. Again, not everyone finds those movies their cup of tea, but I love them.
Cidade de Deus is definitely in my top 20 films of all time. It really is a remarkably powerful film.
I'll give it a shot.
I also like the Suicide Kings, Virgin Suicides (seems to be a theme here), and Green Street Hooligans.
Cidade de Deus = City of God
Oh, Eli
Enter your email address to join: