Why are you guys feeding the troll? Thankfully, he has absolutely no input on pieces being made. This Red Sonja piece is definitely a showstopper but there will always be those that, for whatever reason, have to justify to themselves why they won't be getting her (or any other piece). It is great for everyone to share their honest opinions (both what they like and what they aren't as crazy about) but it isn't okay, in my opinion, for others to argue for the sake of arguing while trying to convince others that THEIR view is the only correct one (while also potentially manipulating what has been previously stated by any of the other parties involved).
You have to wonder why someone who doesn't like a given sculpt still follows, repeatedly comments adversely and otherwise hangs out in a given thread. If you notice that, simply don't feed the troll; if there is no food, they tend to move on.