thenammagazine
Super Freak
Like I said, I wouldn't have a problem with them upgrading older figures. The value might go down, but that's not the only reason we collect, is it? This is cool, badass stuff. Having a company that's become as skilled as HT go back to our favorite characters and pumping them up would be great. And the relative cheapness upon release could keep older collectors happy too -- especially if the sculpts and paint apps are totally different.
But... HT hasn't been known to do that in the past. They'll release variants out the yin-yang, but no redos or upgrades. Maybe there's a reason for that, perhaps the same one everyone else here has agreed upon.
As for your question on secondary market value, like Nam said, it's not really the sellers that encourage the price to increase. It's the buyers. A seller of any product will price their items at the maximum amount he/she thinks the public is willing to pay. So when a HT Predator 2 Elder usually goes for $600 and then someone bids $700, in many cases that will become the new price. There is somewhat of a limit, I mean the P2 Elder also went for over 1K at a certain point, though we all know that was an exaggeration and it's unlikely for it to happen again. Still, we (the buyers) control the pricing up to a certain degree.
If there's an older piece you want, save up for it and don't buy any of the new stuff. Wait a few months until you have enough money, then get that coveted piece you never thought you'd own. Crossing a line and working for it can add even more reward to your figure.
My point exactly. Stop expecting everything for nothing. If you're not willing to put any effort into it, you don't deserve it.