This thread/poll almost makes me wish TDK was a comic book movie so I could compare them.
The Avengers VS The Dark Knight
- Thread starter OSCORP
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
- Status
Something Sexy
Super Freak
Tough to say but here is my input on this topic.
I usually base my choice with these types of comparisons on which movie I could rewatch more. My choice as of now would The Avengers. I enjoyed the overall character interactions much more and the movie was a lot more fluid and it felt like one whole movie, where TDK to me, feels like two movies in one.
I usually base my choice with these types of comparisons on which movie I could rewatch more. My choice as of now would The Avengers. I enjoyed the overall character interactions much more and the movie was a lot more fluid and it felt like one whole movie, where TDK to me, feels like two movies in one.
Chapter 2099
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2008
- Messages
- 29,762
- Reaction score
- 24
Re: Avengers VS Dark Knight
Understatement of the year.
For me, these two are two totally different 'beasts.' Both mastered their approach/technique though. If it was a question of two movies, same characters, which did it better, etc.....I'd say things might be more clearly defined, but this will boil down to a Marvel vs. D.C. debate, I presume.
What the heck, submitted my vote. This thread should be interesting
Understatement of the year.
For me, these two are two totally different 'beasts.' Both mastered their approach/technique though. If it was a question of two movies, same characters, which did it better, etc.....I'd say things might be more clearly defined, but this will boil down to a Marvel vs. D.C. debate, I presume.
fosing
Super Freak
one thing is certain though.... that spiderman movie cant compete with these 2.
hairlesswookiee
PALPATINE CRUSADER!!!!
I'm not really interested in seeing the new Spiderman, but that's just my bitterness about the reboot so soon. It does look good in the sense that it really looks like a better adaptation of the comics.
EVILFACE
Insufferable S.O.B.
The Avengers was funner.
The Dark Knight is the better movie.
What hurts Avengers for me is The Phantom Menace ending and including lame ducks Fury, Hawkeye and Black Widow.
The Dark Knight is the better movie.
What hurts Avengers for me is The Phantom Menace ending and including lame ducks Fury, Hawkeye and Black Widow.
fosing
Super Freak
i think it would've helped if fury bleeped a lot. not even a mother____er. :/
I refuse to vote. Too tough to call right now. Though TDK kinda drags a bit toward the end in a way that Avengers doesn't....
My God, stupid post of the day. As a comic fan I enjoyed The Avengers more. For me TDK is not really a comic book movie and is not true to how the writers wrote Batman. Its very much Nolans vision and is brilliant. But if I were to chose it would be Avengers.
intothevoid
Super Freak
Agree with first part
Could argue all day about 2nd part
You think TDK is a reflection of the comics? BTW I love the movie but its an action movie which Batman and the Joker just happen to be in. Not saying a comic book version would be any more successful or not.
Easy choice for me. And I know you all know what I chose. I just didn't have any connection to TDK and I was praying it would end as soon as it began. Much like the Cap A. movie.
But every movie and character has their fans. TDK has plenty of em, I'm just not one of them.
But every movie and character has their fans. TDK has plenty of em, I'm just not one of them.
EVILFACE
Insufferable S.O.B.
How was it stupid?
Phantom Menace = Anakin destroys control ship and robots instantly stopped, heroes win.
Avengers = Iron Man destroys control ship and robots instantly stopped, heroes win.
Or are you refering to Hawkeye, Black Widow and Fury?
Yea, Fury wasn't that bad but the other two are pointless in a movie like this. BW super power is a pair of Glock 9mms and hawtness. Hawkeye has super powers untill he runs out of arrows.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
what's this crap now.
I'm going to cheat!
Avengers/BB/TDK are tied for best superhero movies.
Sorry, but Nolan's movies are indeed regarded as superhero movies.
Now if you put a gun on my head and force me to break the tie, well, it depends on who's holding the gun.
If void, then BB
If Buffygirl, then Avengers
P.S. I voted for Avengers when void sneezed while holding the gun.
I'm going to cheat!
Avengers/BB/TDK are tied for best superhero movies.
Sorry, but Nolan's movies are indeed regarded as superhero movies.
Now if you put a gun on my head and force me to break the tie, well, it depends on who's holding the gun.
If void, then BB
If Buffygirl, then Avengers
P.S. I voted for Avengers when void sneezed while holding the gun.
what's this crap now.
I'm going to cheat!
Avengers/BB/TDK are tied for best superhero movies.
Sorry, but Nolan's movies are indeed regarded as superhero movies.
Now if you put a gun on my head and force me to break the tie, well, it dependswho's holding the gun.
If void, then BB
If Buffygirl, then Avengers
Consider it me then.
I will make a pic of my head on Widow's body as she points her gun.
- Joined
- Sep 8, 2006
- Messages
- 16,367
- Reaction score
- 526
Avengers by a mile for me.
It's funny that after 3 years of listening to "TDK is the greatest comic book movie ever" now suddenly it shouldn't be compared to other comic book movies.
It's funny that after 3 years of listening to "TDK is the greatest comic book movie ever" now suddenly it shouldn't be compared to other comic book movies.
intothevoid
Super Freak
I think it's a reflection of the comics in terms of the characters and what they represent. In particular, the relationship between Batman and Joker I think is handled pitch perfectly, the interrogation scene is a perfect embodiment of that.
Avengers by a mile for me.
It's funny that after 3 years of listening to "TDK is the greatest comic book movie ever" now suddenly it shouldn't be compared to other comic book movies.
I never considered TDK a real comic book movie.
Eukalyptus
Super Freak
Though I will enjoy TDKR, Avengers takes the cake. Joss Whedon is just king.
- Status
